MEMBER LOGIN






Search First Things

Advanced Search

RSS

First Thoughts
Archive

Monthly


« Previous  |Home|  Next »         

Friday, June 12, 2009, 2:29 PM
Nathaniel Peters

Last winter I went to a conference in Seattle and had the chance to walk by Pike Place Fish. Aside from the gorgeous spread of Pacific seafood—king crabs, salmons, the works—the main eye-catcher was that the employees tossed the catch from one to another as they wrapped and sold the fish.

Recently the folks from Pike Place Fish were hired by a veterinarians’ conference to give a presentation on the value of teamwork on the job—a presentation that would involve acts of fish-tossing. But the folks at PETA heard about it and they were not happy. As they wrote to the organization of veterinarians: “You should know that people who care about animals are appalled that a veterinary organization, whose purpose is to represent the interests of those whose jobs involve protecting the well-being of animals would promote an event in which animals are treated so disrespectfully and are handled as if they were toys.”

One could move from here to a discussion as to why animals and their bodies do not, in fact, have quite the dignity that PETA would attribute to them. But the Seattle Times simply noted the obvious:

Fish have some kind of feelings when living. But fish used in the famous fish toss are not nursing a wound or evaluating their sense of self worth. They are dead. The next best thing that can happen to a salmon is to be topped with lemon and butter, barbecued and then eaten.

Mmmmmm. A pity the folks from PETA will never know the joy of a tossed and barbecued salmon. And I hope they never happen upon even more egregious affronts to the self worth of fishes. . . .

3 Comments

    First Thoughts — A First Things Blog
    June 12th, 2009 | 5:56 pm

    [...] Nathaniel, I believe that that should properly be written, “Shame on the Sea Kitten [...]

    vonMise
    June 14th, 2009 | 2:18 am

    I don’t know if it was noted on First Things but, directly following the terrible killing in Wichita, PETA put up advertising that had baby chickens on it. Implying and stating in several ways that you may be prochoice or prolife but everyone should be against chicken abortions. Totally abhorrent stuff even for Feminists I happened to read later on in the day. I no longer stand PETA period and encourage everyone else to state reasonably why they are selfish prigs.

    Items of note (6/15/09) : Theopolitical
    June 15th, 2009 | 11:55 am

    [...] Nathaniel Peters brings our attention to the travesty of the Pike Place fish toss. [...]