SUBSCRIBER LOGIN






Search First Things

Advanced Search
« Previous  |Home|  Next »         

Thursday, November 12, 2009, 5:02 PM

E.J. Dionne writes a pretty good column: Don’t Let Abortion Destroy Health Care Reform:

From the outraged comments of the abortion rights movement, you’d think that Rep. Bart Stupak’s amendment to the House version of the health care bill would all but overturn Roe v. Wade. No, it wouldn’t. . . . What happens now? Democratic supporters of abortion rights need to accept that their House majority depends on a large cadre of anti-abortion colleagues. They can denounce that reality, or they can learn to live with it.

There are knee-jerk element in it, all reflecting Dionne’s belief that no one of any morality could possibly oppose the reforms: “There is also a challenge for abortion’s foes, above all the Catholic bishops who have a long history of supporting universal coverage but devoted most of their recent energy to the abortion battle. How much muscle will the bishops now put behind the broader effort to pass health care reform? Their credibility as advocates for social justice hangs in the balance.”

But E.J. Dionne is at least right that if we must have the reform, the Stupak amendment is the only way to make it palatable.

2 Comments

    Marv
    November 12th, 2009 | 5:24 pm

    Without our knowledge, our eldest daughter had an abortion in her mid 20s during a time of great duress. Thankfully, her younger sister told us and also directed her to Project Rachel, which helped her tremendously (she still does not know that we know). She is now married and has two more children. Little Julia is in heaven awaiting with great hope and anticipation the arrival of her family some day.
    Health care is important, but *come on*! …

    Phil Swain
    November 13th, 2009 | 8:25 am

    The bishops have to energetically lobby for the House bill in order to have any credibility as advocates for social justice. Why? Apparently, Dionne is calling in his chit from the bishops for his support for Stupak-Pitts. We gave you what you wanted now give us what we want. That’s an interesting concept of the role of a Catholic Bishop.

Links

Blogs

Find Us

Contact