Why does modern buildings tend to look so harsh and feel so unhospitable? Michael Mehaffy and Nikos A. Salingaros say its because the designer literally suffer from “architectural myopia”:
Have you ever looked at a bizarre building design and wondered, “What were the architects thinking?” Have you looked at a supposedly “ecological” industrial-looking building, and questioned how it could be truly ecological? Or have you simply felt frustrated by a building that made you uncomfortable, or felt anger when a beautiful old building was razed and replaced with a contemporary eyesore? You might be forgiven for thinking “these architects must be blind!” New research shows that in a real sense, you might actually be right.
Environmental psychologists have long known about this widespread and puzzling phenomenon. Laboratory results show conclusively that architects literally see the world differently from non-architects. Not only do architects notice and look for different aspects of the environment than other people; their brains seem to synthesize an understanding of the world that has notable differences from natural reality. Instead of a contextual world of harmonious geometric relationships and connectedness, architects tend to see a world of objects set apart from their contexts, with distinctive, attention-getting qualities.
There are many such confirming studies. For example, Gifford et al. (2002) surveyed other research and noted that “architects did not merely disagree with laypersons about the aesthetic qualities of buildings, they were unable to predict how laypersons would assess buildings, even when they were explicitly asked to do so.” The researchers traced this disagreement to well-known cognitive differences in the two populations: “Evidence that certain cognitive properties are related to building preference [was] found.”




October 25th, 2011 | 10:49 am
There is a saying attributed to Frank Lloyd Wright: “Doctor’s bury their mistakes. Architects can only plant lots of vines.” I have no idea whether it is a real quote, but it seems on target.
October 25th, 2011 | 11:04 am
The same could be said of software architects/programmers.
October 25th, 2011 | 2:00 pm
and high fashion designers.
October 25th, 2011 | 7:07 pm
This is applicable to all arts; if an artistic community is isolated from prevailing social opinions, their art develops into something that is basically a conversation with other artists. In the past, economic pressures pretty much forced artists to produce art that was pleasing to the general public; since all art has been essentially turned into an academic discipline in our time, it should come as no surprise that it has developed a touch of the Ivory Tower syndrome associated with those environments.
October 27th, 2011 | 1:10 am
Many modern buildings look like box-shaped prisons to me. I cannot stand to see a big dark brown rectangular box, with rows of little sparse square windows.
Architect should be hanged in the public square nearest to the aggrieving building.
Links
Blogs
Find Us
Contact