I love dear old England. I spent five wonderful years in Oxford, first as a graduate student and then as a visiting scholar. Although I am a republican by political philosophy, I have a soft spot in my heart for Queen Elizabeth. She is a patriotic and hard working woman who displays a keen sense of duty.
Her close relatives by blood and marriage have been a seemingly endless source of embarrassment to her, but she has handled the family scandals in as dignified a way as possible. And she has functioned in the way a modern constitutional monarch should function: as an embodiment of the nation’s values and as a symbol of its unity.
Despite my republican sympathies, I’d like to see the monarchy survive. It links modern Britain to a history which, while not unsullied, has its glories. On that score, however, the antics and poor judgment of the Queen’s relatives are a problem. Ordinary people (most of whom are fond of the Queen herself) don’t appreciate bad behavior by the royals.
It would help if the gang would just follow some relatively simple rules. They could begin, for example, with this one: When you leave your home or hotel room, wear clothing and don’t take it off. I mean, honestly, is that asking too much? Members of the Japanese imperial family seem to manage to keep their clothes on. No one is going to manage to snap a picture of a naked Crown Prince Naruhito or a topless Princess Masako. Why should pictures of a naked Prince Harry or a topless Kate Middleton be floating around? It is, as they say, an avoidable problem.
Of course, the Japanese imperials tend to stick to the private sphere, but I am reminded of the small role I and my family played in getting the current Crown Prince out a bit. My brother Keith was Naruhito’s best friend when they were students together in Oxford. (They have remained close ever since. Keith was one of the few Westerners at his wedding reception.)
I was a graduate student at Oxford at the time, as were two more of my brothers, Kent and Edward. Keith and the Prince (“Hiro” as he was then known) used to come over to my house sometimes — I was aleady married by then, and was the only one with a house — and that was considered by the Prince’s attendants (and security people) to be a big step into the outer world.
We decided that the next step was to take him out to an old-fashioned English pub. That, of course, was a challenge. In fact, it was pretty clear that it was a cause of controversy among those responsible for looking out for the Prince. In the end, though, the “modernizers” won, and he went out with us for a pint of ale.
At the end of the evening, I recall that he very deliberately reached into his pocket and pulled out a ten pound note to cover his share. I suspect that it was the first time in his life he had ever paid for something himself or even had money in his possession. He seemed to enjoy the entire evening, especially the paying!
The next step we had in mind was impossible—or so we were told. We cooked up a plan for him to visit our family at home in West Virginia. Hiro clearly wanted to do it, but this was a decision that could only be made by the powers in Tokyo. Again, there was division. Miraculously, though, the Chamberlain (a wonderful man named Dr. Fuji, who deeply believed that the younger royals should not be excessively sheltered from the world) prevailed and the trip was arranged.
It happened in the summer after Keith and Hiro completed their studies. Wonderfully, the Prince and his entourage made a stop to visit my wife and me in Princeton on his way to West Virginia. We hosted a party for him with officials of the University and members of the faculty who were interested in Japanese history, culture, and politics.
I was a brand new assistant professor, and getting a visit from the Prince was, to say the least, a news item on campus. (I happened to know that the Prince was a fan of the actress Brooke Shields, who was a student here at the time. I arranged for them to be introduced, and they ended up forming a nice friendship. She even visited him in Japan, which caused something of a sensation. He was unmarried and unattached at the time.)
We all (well, not Brooke) went together, then, to West Virgnia, followed by three busloads of Japanese reporters and photographers. We took him to see a coal mine and other sites, and had a reception at our home where we pulled out the banjos and guitars and played some bluegrass music. He is a classically trained violinist, and we tried our best that evening to convert him and Dr. Fuji, who accompanied him and also played the violin, into bluegrass fiddlers. In this, I must confess, we were not entirely successful. They gave it their best shot, though. I guess we hit what might be called a “cultural divide.”




September 22nd, 2012 | 4:16 pm
I love the stories about Prince Hiro – wonderful! And you are so right; if the clothes stay on there can be no scandalous photos to later surface.
September 22nd, 2012 | 6:45 pm
I think it should be noted however that Kate and William are married and there is nothing scandalous about their behavior, perhaps better judgment could have been made on the location they chose to go sun bathing, perhaps not, I don’t know, I haven’t followed closely enough.
September 22nd, 2012 | 9:18 pm
Oh come now, the topless-Kate flap is hardly the same thing as Harry’s shenanigans. She takes her shirt off to sunbathe on a private vacation with her husband, on a private beach, in the middle of nowhere, in the South-of-Frace, where everyone goes topless anyway. And the paparazzi spy on them! Kate’s behavior is hardly the problem here.
The stories you tell of Prince Hiro (which are so lovely!) only accentuates the point: sometimes Royals need to be regular people too. And if the paparazzi weren’t so dogged in their pursuit of the British Royal family, maybe they’d have a chance to be so.
September 22nd, 2012 | 11:16 pm
Lovely story… I admire Queen Elizabeth too, but “hard working?” Come on, that’s insulting to people who really do work for a living.
September 23rd, 2012 | 7:58 am
I love the tales of the Japanese crown prince, but am distracted by the impressive achievement of the George family—four sons at Oxford? Wow.
September 23rd, 2012 | 7:24 pm
Lovely story… I admire Queen Elizabeth too, but “hard working?” Come on, that’s insulting to people who really do work for a living.
She has an extensive schedule of public appearances and mounds of state papers to read. She is still at it at the age of 86.
–
The Duchess of Cambridge’s privacy was invaded, but as a rule the only person who should see you topless is your husband.
September 23rd, 2012 | 9:51 pm
If I were formulating the laws of a constitutional monarchy, I might contemplate letting the sovereign retain the right to arbitrarily execute one member of the media each year. At least so long as it was their only power.
September 23rd, 2012 | 10:26 pm
What a great essay! Patrick: Queen Elizabeth is hard-working, or at least she used to be (don’t know about now in her elderly years). It is hard work to represent your country at event after event, day after day, year after year, sometimes several times a day. Being on display like that, talking to hundreds of people, always having to look just so and be perfect no matter how you feel or what you think or what you’d rather be doing… it may not seem like working, but it is.
September 24th, 2012 | 4:21 am
I should imagine the life of a constitutional combines tedium and irritation in an uncommon degree
As Seneca says, “Parva si non fiunt quotidie” [These things would be trivial, if they did not have to be endured daily]
Links
Blogs
Find Us
Contact