Debate adversaries are called anti-science most commonly during intense disagreements about the proper ethical parameters to establish over controversial areas of scientific inquiry. For example, the embryonic stem cell research (ESCR) debate isnt primarily about stem cell science. Rather, the controversy surrounds the ethical propriety of destroying human embryos as if they were no more important than a corn crop. Throw the potential for developing non-contentious stem cell alternatives into the discussionsuch as adult stem cellsand you have a real policy donnybrook.
Read the rest here . If you’re already reading Smith’s blog over at National Review Online and would like to read some other intelligent writing on science and ethics, I suggest checking out The New Atlantis (here’s a symposium on embryos and another issue dedicated to stem cell research .)
And if you, like me, are not quite Irish enough to know the word donnybrook, Merriam-Webster is here to help .