Legislation has been introduced that would give a tax credit for 30% of legal costs incurred, maximum $500, for the legal expenses incurred in filling out an advance health care directive (HR 2705). The hope, I am sure, is that people will eschew extensive efforts to save themselves, and thereby, preserve health care resources.
I believe in advance directives, but I think people should make careful and informed decisions about what care they would not want–and be able to decide that they want their lives saved–a “choice” explicitly threatened by Futile Care Theory.
As for the bill, I am relatively indifferent. I don’t think it will induce a lot of people to go to a lawyer and create an advance directive. Most who fail to create directives don’t do so out of discomfort about thinking of their own mortality and potential debilitation, not out of worry about the legal costs. This is short sighted because the best time to fill out these legal documents is when there is time to think hard about the choices, not when entering a hospital or in a crisis. (For anyone interested, the International Euthanasia Task Force on Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide offers for a very modest fee, a state-specific advance advance directive called the Protective Medical Decision Document, or PMDD, a durable power of attorney-type document in which the signer rejects euthanasia and dehydration.)
Here’s a deal: We pass the bill and outlaw Futile Care Theory at the same time. That would be a real win-win.
June 9th, 2009 | 5:29 pm
“Here’s a deal: We pass the bill and outlaw Futile Care Theory at the same time. That would be a real win-win.”
Wesley for President!
June 9th, 2009 | 5:54 pm
I am just fed up with all the government’s use of taxes to surreptitiously manipulate behavior, for good or ill.
June 9th, 2009 | 9:17 pm
CollegeGoyl: Indeed. SafePres: I thought you liked me!
June 10th, 2009 | 12:56 am
Hmmm…your right. On second thought: “Wesley for National Health Secretary!”
June 10th, 2009 | 10:29 am
“(For anyone interested, the International Euthanasia Task Force on Euthanasia and Assisted Suicide offers for a very modest fee, a state-specific advance advance directive called the Protective Medical Decision Document, or PMDD, a durable power of attorney-type document in which the signer rejects euthanasia and dehydration.)”
Forgive me. It’s very early for me, and I just did the mental equivalent of putting both feet through one pant leg. I keep forgetting that the Taskforce is *anti-Euthanasia.*
Good for them to offer it. I need to get a copy eventually. I love my mother but she’s sometimes a little too expedient. Hee. Naw, actually, I’ve made my preferences known to my family and friends.
June 10th, 2009 | 12:37 pm
@CollegeGoyl. How true. The efforts of the federal government to manipulate the lives of people are getting scarier by the moment.
Links
Blogs
Find Us
Contact