SUBSCRIBER LOGIN






Search First Things

Advanced Search

RSS

Secondhand Smoke
Archives

Categories

Monthly


« Previous  |Home|  Next »         

Friday, January 22, 2010, 12:00 PM
Wesley J. Smith

The Washington Examiner reported today, as noted here, that Obamacare is officially dead.  Other news outlets have merely said it is is dying, with life support soon to be removed.  Whichever it is, the people clearly want to go in a different direction.

As an illustration, Gallup has a poll headline, “Majority Favors Suspending Work on Healthcare Bill,” that seems a bit, if unintentionally, misleading. The majority doesn’t want to pursue Obamacare as currently proposed, true.  But that isn’t the same thing as suspending work on reform, as indicated by the question asked by the pollsters. From the poll:

What do you think President Obama and the Democrats in Congress should do now concerning a health care reform bill–should they continue to try and pass the healthcare bill now being worked out by Democrats in the House and Senate (39%) or suspend work on the current healthcare bill the House and Senate are working on and consider alternative bills that can receive more Republican support (56%)?

The Obamacare political debate is over, with the societal hegemonists once again–as in Hillarycare–having lost the debate.  But that shouldn’t be the end of it.  Our representatives should heed this poll and get to work on targeted fixes.  If they don’t, if our current governors just call it a day, it will confirm an as yet unproved suspicion in my mind that the leaders of the Democratic Party wanted a health care takeover to gain control over most aspects of our lives more than they wanted to fix what is actually broken.

6 Comments

    David
    January 22nd, 2010 | 1:48 pm

    Well, the majority of Americans support embryonic stem cell research, so that debate is over, too, right?

    The majority of scientists (especially climatologists >95%) say global warming is real and man plays a significant role in it; therefore the debate is over.

    Does anyone seriously think the Democrats (look at their congressional leaders!) are capable of getting any meaningful reform or fix through, be it healthcare, campaign finance, insurance, or banking? Their two Congressional leaders are Beavis and Butthead and they are supposed to lead a bunch of pc vanity whores.

    I recommend folks check out some of these polls:

    http://www.pollingreport.com/science.htm

    (one of the most interesting was at the end whereby, supposedly, 27% of 1025 American adults claim to have “been in a tornado”. Yeah, we aren’t a delusional or idiotic country. [kind of like how everyone doesn't think they personally are fat, yet, somehow, some odd 70% of the country is] Gosh, all those people having actually been in funnel clouds; the gods are taking great care of us)

    Wesley J. Smith Reply:

    Actually David, the fight over Bush’s funding policy is over. The fight over ESCR is far less intense because of IPSCs. It will take off again when the attempt is made to fund human cloning. The debate over Obamacare is similarly over, but not the best way to fund health care reform. Nuance, David. Please.

    Obamacare: Majority Want to Pursue Different Approach » Secondhand … Tools
    January 22nd, 2010 | 4:17 pm

    [...] Obamacare: Majority Want to Pursue Different Approach » Secondhand … Tags: brakes, county, favors-suspending, gallup, its-current, obamacare-as-currently, poll-headline, poll-out, poll-out-today, president, president-obama, the-wake, today-shows Poll: Majority Of Americans Wants Dems To Suspend Work On Health …An Orwellian Moment: NYT Editors Declare 60 Votes a "Majority" of …Fox Confident Majority of Affiliates Could Clear a Conan Show …WakeEd – Calling the school board majority criminals …RealClearPolitics – Majority Favors Suspending Work on Health CareObama Squandered Democratic Political Capital in 2009SUNLIT UPLANDS: On 37th Anniversary of Roe v. Wade Poll Finds …Did Martha Coakley kill health reform, and what Senator Scott …Poll suggests political consequences from U.S. healthcare deal …RealClearPolitics – HorseRaceBlog – The Political Blunders of the … View the Contact Powered by Tools [...]

    HistoryWriter
    January 22nd, 2010 | 8:56 pm

    To paraphrase Honest Abe and characterize the anti-healthcare crowd: “You can fool most of the people a lot of the time — and that’s all it takes.”

    Obamacare: Majority Want to Pursue Different Approach » Secondhand … Blog
    January 22nd, 2010 | 11:48 pm

    [...] Obamacare: Majority Want to Pursue Different Approach » Secondhand … Tags: 20th-2009, clearly-want, favors, gallup, majority-favors, passing-over, poll-headline, steep-climb, swooping-out, the-people, the-sky, thoughts-same Country Captures: A Different BirdLimerick TDs offer different opinions on banking crisis inquiry …Different header and footer for admin panel and site | drupal.orgWhat are the Different Weight Loss Surgeries and the Associated …3 Different Handicap Bathtubs Options | DoItYourself.comSame Kind of Different as Me « Care's Online Book ClubA look at the new batting practice caps | River Avenue BluesTamsin Rothschild:Habs return to practice tomorrow | Habs Inside/OutHaiti Earthquake on Tape View the Contact Powered by Blog [...]

    College Goyl
    January 23rd, 2010 | 11:17 am

    Not anti-healthcare, HW, “anti-this-particular-travesty-of-a-bill.” Again, such a fine distinction.

Links

Blogs

Find Us

Contact