MEMBER LOGIN




Search First Things

Advanced Search

RSS

The Anchoress
Archives

Categories

Monthly


Recent Posts







Shop on-line at www.aquinasandmore.com
Find Me...








Email The Anchoress




The Joyful Mysteries
The Sorrowful Mysteries
The Glorious Mysteries
The Luminous Mysteries
Compline for 7 Nights
Litany Sacred Heart Jesus



Advertise on this blog









Bl. Pier Giorgio Frassati
Pray for Us




St. Philip Neri, my '10 Patron






Catholic New Media Awards

The 2008 Weblog Awards

The 2007 Weblog Awards

The 2006 Weblog Awards







Blogroll

Abbey St.Walburga
Ace O' Spades
Adoration Online
Afterburner
A Few Shiny Pebbles
A.J. Strata
Amy Alkon
Another Think
Ann Althouse
And You Thought/Cranky
Ambivablog
American Digest
American Thinker
American Papist
Archbishop Hilarion
Archbishop Timothy Dolan
Aussie Homilies
Bainbridge
Baldilocks
Betsy's Page
Beyond the Pale
Big Hollywood
BizzyBlog
Blue Crab Blvd
Bill Whittle
Bookworm Room
Brutally Honest
Busted Halo
Cardinal Sean's Blog
Catholic and Enjoying It
Catholic Answers
Catholic Manhattan
Catholic Media Review
Cathouse Chat
Cartago Delenda Est
Catholic Key
Classical Values
Cobb
Concord Pastor
Creative Minority Report
Crescat
Compulsive Copyeditor
Confederate Yankee
Contentions
Conversion Diary
Curt Jester
Danielle Bean
Dave Justus
David Warren
Dawn Eden
Day by Day Cartoon
Deacon's Bench
Desert Nuns
Divine Office (Daily Audio)
Doc is In
Doctor Zero
Dominican Nuns, Summit
Don Singleton
Don Surber
Doug Ross Journal
Dr. Melissa Clouthier
Dr. Helen
Dr. Sanity
Ed Driscoll
Eternity Road
Evangelical Outpost
Ezra Levant
Fausta's Blog
Fine Old Family
Five Feet of Fury
Flopping Aces
FSMG Blog
Fr. Dwight Longenecker
Fr. Steve's Blog
G.M. Roper
Gateway Pundit
Gay Patriot
Goldfish & Clowns
Happy Catholic
Headline Bistro
HillBuzz
Hootsbuddy
Hot Air
Hubble Telescope
In Light of Law
Ignatius Insight Scoop
Inside Catholic
Instapundit
J's CafeNette
Jules Crittenden
Just One Minute
Kentucky Packrat
Kim Priestap
Life as a Catholic
Little Miss Attila
Little Flowers
Little Oratory
Liturgy of the Hours
Lorie Byrd
Lucianne
Maggie's Farm
Mahsheed's Corner
Martha, Martha
Maternal Optimist
Mary's Aggies
Maxed Out Mama
McNamara's Blog
Meanwhile/in the Kitchen
Media Mythbusters
Michelle Malkin
Mike Rowe Works
Minding the Campus
Moderate Voice
Monsastic Musings
Musing Minds
My VRWC
Neo-Neocon
New Advent
New Wine
Newsbusters
NewsFifty
Noisy Room Blog
Nose on your Face (satire)
Obi's Sister
Okie on the Lam
One Cosmos
Paragraph Farmer
Passionist Nuns
Patterico
Paul Snatchko
People's Cube
Planet Gore
Phatmass
Pioneer Woman
Pope2You
Powerline Blog
Protein Wisdom
Pursuing Holiness
Stones Cry Out
Sundries Shack
Rachel Lucas
Radiate His Light
Real Clear Politics
Right Wing News
Right Wing Nuthouse
Roman Catholic Vocations
Runs With Angels
Scribal Terror
Shrinkwrapped
Sissy Willis
Sister Toldjah
Small Dead Animals
Some Have Hats
Spiritual Things Matter
Sponsa-Christi
Sr. Genevieve Glen, OSB
St. Joseph's Monastery
St. Vincent's Abbey
Stop the ACLU
Sweetness & Light
Tammy Bruce
Team Rubicon
Tigerhawk
Tim Blair
Villainous Company
Visitation Sisters
Vita Nostra In Ecclesia
Volokh Conspiracy
WDTPRS
Western Chauvinist
Witnessing Hope
Whispers in the Loggia
Wide Awake Cafe
Wintery Knight Blog
Wizbang
Word on Fire
Why I Am Catholic

« Previous  |Home|  Next »         

Thursday, September 11, 2008, 3:29 PM
TheAnchoress

Look at that picture. Look at the protective grasp with which Gov. Sarah Palin holds her dear son, Trig. Look at her expression. Look at her eyes. That is one tough babe; that is no woman to be toyed with. That is a woman who’d as soon drop you as look at you, if who or what she loves is being threatened.

Dirty Harry’s commenters have some ideas about “why they hate her,” and they’re interesting, funny, sometimes profane, but the one I quoted above hits closest to the mark. They hate her because she is not a victim. And she does not see her son as a victim. And one gets the sense that she has no patience for disaffected drama queens with pretensions to victimhood, or with people who make their livings tearing down instead of building up, in order to keep the victim-mentality alive.

They hate her and they can’t bring themselves under control.
You’d think after the first rush of wilding, the first cathartic release of boorish and hysterical screams, these people would be able to calm down a little, to get rational, to look beyond the ad hominem. You’d think it, but you’d be wrong.

So, on this day of tragic memory, in the year of our Lord, 2008, after 40 years of solid consensus about the abilities, rights, choices and empowerments of women, I present this run-down of uncontrolled and vile hate, directed toward a woman of ability, who has worked within her rights, made her choices and revealed the unwieldy and hard-to-control, startling power of her womanhood and her authentic feminine genius. She seems to have driven these people (both male and female, but the women are by far the worst) into the self-destructive revelation that they are ugly, vulgar and tawdry; and even if they could manage to re-hang their curtains, we’ve seen the truth.

Today I’ve been most taken with the incoherent ravings of this pathetic professor, Wendy Doniger, of U. Chicago’s Divinity School – she is an academic who mistaken believes that notion of (and the very phrase) “the separation of church and state” is actually included in “the mother lovin’ constitution!” She also is of the opinion that Mrs. Palin, demonstrably female, is not really a woman, although Joe Biden might be. Read her ravings and wonder at them. This old-time deconstructionist female – quite possibly an affirmative action hire meant to “empower” women – is writing in a weekly column that purports to be about issues of faith, but never explores that issue except through the prism of liberal politics. Doniger actually has little of value to say about Sarah Palin, but she is an ear-splitting, conscience-searing siren, alerting us to social, theological and educational travesties that have gone too long unexamined.

Hard on Doniger’s heels, almost surpassing her by the sheer force of her long expulsion of gas, is Heather Mallick’s mighty wind of hate. You can read it or you can do better, and read James Lilek’s exquisite fisking of her rant. Clearly Mallick approves of women, but not of females, and she too seems to have trouble distinguishing men from males. What an odd crew. Neo-neocon says more attention must be paid to these women, but not because of their wisdom; because of their weirdness.

That brings us to Cintra Wilson who – upon consideration – might be the most offensive and over-the-top of these Sneer Sisters.

Sarah Palin and her virtual burqa have me and my friends retching into our handbags. She’s such a power-mad, backwater beauty-pageant casualty, it’s easy to write her off and make fun of her. But in reality I feel as horrified as a ghetto Jew watching the rise of National Socialism.

She is dangerous. She is not just pro-life, she’s anti-life. She is the suppression of human feeling and instinct. She is a slave to the compromises dictated by her own desire for power and control. Sarah Palin is untethered from her own needs and those of her family, which is in crisis, with a pregnant daughter, a son on the way to Iraq and a special-needs infant.

There is no response to that. The “she’s anti-life; suppression of human feelings and instincts…” argument betrays this as the equivalent of a Junior High School editorial by a 14 year old of some promise whose emotional growth was touched by frost and stunted. Dr. Sanity diagnosis underlying psychosis.

I’ll link to other Palinsanity further down, but now I recommend you take the antidote to The Weird Sisters by reading in full Camille Paglia’s exquisitely reasoned and written exposition on this descent in to madness, what does and means to feminism, and to women; how it exposes their fears and insecurities and – most importantly – how their inability to discuss abortion with intellectual and emotional honesty will be their ruination. As well as Paglia articulates it all, even she cannot get into the sickness fully enough. Still, she gets closer than anyone and this is a powerful piece – searingly honest about women, society and even herself.

What struck me about Paglia’s piece – and it must be read, it is too good to excerpt – is how her Catholic upbringing and education is so obviously the basis for her strength of mind; even if she has rejected all that, she has done it in a muscular and forthright way. I hesitated to say that earlier in the week because – as a Catholic – I am sensitive to being seen as “pushing” Catholic angles when talking politics. But Kathy Shaidle said it well: You can’t take the “Catholic school” out of the girl…

Lest we forget the men, they are leaving their spittle-laced diatribes all about as well. Caution at that link – you need an umbrella to stay dry from the foaming at the mouth.

No less an intellectual giant than film critic Roger Ebert, who once wrote a Valley of the Dolls screenplay, joined in the hissy fit, taking deep offense to the fact that at age 44, Palin has not yet been to Europe! Oddly enough, this massive brain lift was quickly taken down from the internet. Some of it may be found here.

The name-calling proves the arrested adolescence: Palin is “a Christian Stepford Wife!” She is “a cocky wacko!” She is “Osama bin Laden!” She is not deferential enough to Gloria Steinem! Palin is a living, breathing, functioning, three dimensional “MYTH of America, which really isn’t as great as she makes it out to be, and neither is she. Oh…they really hate her. And they lack wit, besides.

Why?

Some say they fear her faith

Some seem terrified by her youngest child and are positively allergic to calling him by his name, which, by the way, is Trig.

Some Canadians are worried that more women will “become confused” and have little Trigs of their own instead of aborting them. I’m not making that up. Others – most of the women – wail about the impending loss of their abortion rights, seemingly they do not understand that THE DEMOCRATS run both houses of congress.

Some recognize, simply, that Palin’s story and her strengths highlight Barack Obama’s weaknesses, the weightiest of which is his megalomania.

The press, lightly spanked for its excesses in the first days and hours of Palin’s emergence does not get why they have been booed. THey are being careful about what you hear, and what they do not disclose. And they’re still superior in tone as they do it. Note also ABC’s Charlie Gibson is misquoting her to her face. They are not really journalists, anymore.

There is a ton of this hateful stuff out there, but there are also a few people on the left willing to hear Palin, and more on the right willing to defend her – enjoy yourself frolicking through them!

“I’m a liberal but I’m blown away by Sarah Palin!”
Palin Energizing Women from All Walks
Palin is Revolution You Can Believe In
She makes a difference.

Palin’s son left for Iraq today. It does not seem extreme to allow her to catch her breath over the events of the last two weeks. But it is also true that the McCain/Palin ticket will have to be twice as substantial as the Obama/Biden ticket if they want half of the grudging respect.

Hmmm…how funny, feminists used to make that victim-complaint all the time. And here is a woman who is no victim, and not to be messed with, who is being made to jump through their victim-hoop. O irony.

Meanwhile, Ed Morrissey takes a microscope to the vomiting New York Times and finds…what do you know…a LOAD of double standards.

Roger Kimball
has more thoughts

And finally, once and for all, for cryin’ out loud
When it mattered, Gov. Palin stood up to Sen. Stevens and dealt the Bridge to Nowhere its death blow. This is something the U.S. Congress and senators Obama and Biden failed to do on multiple occasions.

And while it’s true that John McCain, unlike his running mate, has always opposed pork-barrel earmarks, Sarah Palin, unlike Obama and Biden, did the right thing when it counted most and stopped an egregious example of earmark abuse. And now, of course, Palin has joined McCain in calling for an end to earmarks.

Isn’t it better to come around to the right position than to keep on being wrong?

Yes, it is. But sanity and reason mean nothing to those on whom Palin Madness Syndrome has fallen.

9 Comments

    Dirty Harry’s Place… » Why They Hate Her
    September 11th, 2008 | 3:46 pm | #1

    [...] UPDATE: The Anchoress links and has a whole lot more. [...]

    Jean Balconi
    September 11th, 2008 | 4:11 pm | #2

    I just want to mention the other “dissing” that’s taking place: Mr. Palin is being treated as a non-parent, as if he can’t possibly juggle the responsibilities of his own family. One of my Native American (First Nation) aquaintances said that when she heard the gross rumour about their youngest child’s “true” parentage, she thought of the brutal stereotypes of Indian men as unfit fathers. I found myself actually trying to make her feel better by saying, “They didn’t say it because of his blood; they said it because they think all men are sperm-donors and otherwise useless around the family.”

    Joe Odegaard
    September 11th, 2008 | 4:20 pm | #3

    Of course they fear her faith.

    HNAV
    September 11th, 2008 | 4:42 pm | #4

    “why they hate her…”

    It is possible, her strength and success threatens the Liberal Partisan Democrat.

    But having watched the overt bigotry, the ugly hatred, the baseless hostility to a number of Republicans over the years, especially the fine Bush Family, I feel strongly it is much deeper.

    The dehumanizing of the Political Opposition has taken over the Liberal Democrat mindset.

    It reminds one of the ugly motives, justifications, basis, some used to convince themselves in their superior nature, which ended up producing World Wars and Genocide.

    Everyone should be careful, as this is not simply related to the treatment of Gov. Palin, GW Bush, etc.

    Anyone who is not a Democrat, preaching the dogma of the modern Politically Correct Liberal Partisan, is now treated with disdain, demeaning, and debasing.

    Certainly, we have witnessed a number of those on the Right, who have embraced a similar political devotion, which dehumanizes their perceived Opposition.

    However the Liberal Democrat bias is affecting so many these days.

    Gov. Palin, GW Bush, Ronald Reagan, Mitt Romney, etc., have been focused upon in a obsessive manner, for they are deemed sincere threats.

    Over time, after much contemplation and analytical study, I began to believe the failure of the Carter Administration, the overt Clinton Negligence, had so embarrassed the Liberal Democrat Partisan, their insecurity grew, and with it came an increase in extreme behavior, as well as demeanor.

    The years of watching the failed efforts of Democrat Governors raise taxation and spending, making poor environments on the local level, has not helped either.

    Democrat Partisans often formed their own political convictions following a fashion, but many were driven with an emotional idealism, believing the Democrat Party is more caring.

    It seems incredible, to have so many fail to study the health of the policies they support. One would believe socialism would be understood, as a weaker system for all today, having watched so many examples produce a more oppressive society. But the basis, evidence, reality, never seems to overcome the emotive embrace.

    Perhaps there are too many special interests, which cloud the judgment of the entire offering. Maybe too many are conflicted with embracing what is best.

    But the ‘feeling’ nature seems to blind, and this enormous bigotry is thus created for those who offer an alternative position. Could it merely be a symptom or product of this denial?

    Regardless, it is sad to watch.

    If one is labeled a ‘Democrat’, all is forgiven, regardless of the overt deceit, corruption, malfeasance. And the Republican, Libertarian, Other, is treated with utter contempt and disgust.

    Unfortunately, the irrational nature of this hatred is growing. GW Bush led the USA, and the rest of the Free World, including Poland, Great Britain, Australia, South Korea, Romania, Italy, Spain, etc., to liberate some 50 Million formerly oppressed Human Beings in Afghanistan and Iraq. Helping these newly freed People, build their Own Free Governments, bringing wonderful potential from what was once a horrid existence.

    And many of these Liberal Democrats filled with such overt bigotry, cannot see this positive. Some even hoped and worked against these admirable endeavors. It is an amazing, regretful reality.

    Some actually have convinced themselves, they would prefer to still have the Butcher of Baghdad pulling the tongues from Iraqi Children, because of their hatred for a Republican who is President.

    irascibleChef
    September 11th, 2008 | 5:09 pm | #5

    Sad news… I’ve been talking to people, people that believe different than me—people that would call themselves open minded, tolerant, feminists, and Liberals, and Democrats.

    They aren’t interested in the truth, the fact that they could be so against someone they don’t know because of articles that aren’t even peer reviewed, not dealing with facts, or truth, or corroboration—is as Matt Damon says, scary! I say astonishing! I’m basing this on the fact that these people want so badly for their side to win that they SEE WHAT THEY BELIEVE and there’s no going back, no willingness to seek the truth. They talk about intolerance, yet they are the most intolerant!

    —IrascibleChef

    dmd25
    September 11th, 2008 | 6:24 pm | #6

    Some seem terrified by her youngest child and are positively allergic to calling him by his name, which, by the way, is Trig.

    If they call Trig by his name, it makes him seem more real–and of course they don’t want that.

    Revchuck
    September 11th, 2008 | 8:38 pm | #7

    From Wendy Doniger’s article:

    “She does not speak for women; she has no sympathy for the problems of other women, particularly working class women.”

    Let’s see, who’s more credble talking about “working class women”…an academic who apparently hasn’t seen the outside of the academy for a while, or a woman who’s partnered with her husband on a fishing boat, been the mayor of a small town and the governor of a large rural state while raising five children? Talk about cognitive dissonance! Sheesh…

    More reax to Palin/ABC (running updates) | The Anchoress
    September 12th, 2008 | 7:11 am | #8

    [...] Palin: “They hate her because she is not a victim” [...]

    docweaselblog
    September 13th, 2008 | 10:11 am | #9

    Educating Sarah…

    In the movie Educating Rita, a naive, honest forthright woman is educated to the point that she has a more erudite and polished way of expressing herself and appreciating literature, but she loses her purity and appealing freshness. This is the danger …