MEMBER LOGIN
Ads




Search First Things

Advanced Search

RSS

The Anchoress
Archives

Categories

Monthly


Recent Posts



Shop on-line at www.aquinasandmore.com
Find Me...








Email The Anchoress







The Joyful Mysteries
The Sorrowful Mysteries
The Glorious Mysteries
The Luminous Mysteries
Compline for 7 Nights
Litany Sacred Heart Jesus



Advertise on this blog


Nuddle Blanket






Bl. Pier Giorgio Frassati
Pray for Us




St. Titus, my '09 Patrion






Catholic New Media Awards

The 2008 Weblog Awards

The 2007 Weblog Awards

The 2006 Weblog Awards







Blogroll

Abbey St.Walburga
Ace O' Spades
Adoration Online
Afterburner
A Few Shiny Pebbles
A.J. Strata
Another Think
Ann Althouse
And You Thought/Cranky
Ambivablog
American Digest
American Thinker
Archbishop Hilarion
Archbishop Timothy Dolan
Aussie Homilies
Bainbridge
Baldilocks
Betsy's Page
Beyond the Pale
Big Hollywood
BizzyBlog
Blue Crab Blvd
Bill Whittle
Bookworm Room
Brutally Honest
Busted Halo
Cardinal Sean's Blog
Catholic Answers
Catholic Manhattan
Catholic Media Review
Cathouse Chat
Cartago Delenda Est
Catholic Key
Classical Values
Cobb
Concord Pastor
Crescat
Compulsive Copyeditor
Confederate Yankee
Contentions
Conversion Diary
Curt Jester
Danielle Bean
Dave Justus
David Warren
Dawn Eden
Day by Day Cartoon
Deacon's Bench
Desert Nuns
Doc is In
Dominican Nuns, Summit
Don Singleton
Don Surber
Doug Ross Journal
Dr. Melissa Clouthier
Dr. Helen
Dr. Sanity
Ed Driscoll
Eternity Road
Evangelical Outpost
Ezra Levant
Fausta's Blog
Fine Old Family
Five Feet of Fury
Flopping Aces
FSMG Blog
Fr. Dwight Longenecker
Fr. Steve's Blog
G.M. Roper
Gateway Pundit
Gay Patriot
Goldfish & Clowns
Happy Catholic
HillBuzz
Hootsbuddy
Hot Air
Hubble Telescope
Inside Catholic
Instapundit
J's CafeNette
Jules Crittenden
Just One Minute
Kentucky Packrat
Kim Priestap
Life as a Catholic
Little Miss Attila
Little Flowers
Liturgy of the Hours
Lorie Byrd
Lucianne
Maggie's Farm
Mahsheed's Corner
Martha, Martha
Maternal Optimist
Maxed Out Mama
McNamara's Blog
Meanwhile/in the Kitchen
Media Mythbusters
Michelle Malkin
Mike Rowe Works
Minding the Campus
Moderate Voice
Monsastic Musings
Musing Minds
My VRWC
Neo-Neocon
New Advent
New Wine
Newsbusters
NewsFifty
Noisy Room Blog
Nose on your Face (satire)
Obi's Sister
Okie on the Lam
One Cosmos
Paragraph Farmer
Passionist Nuns
Patterico
Paul Snatchko
People's Cube
Planet Gore
Phatmass
Pioneer Woman
Powerline Blog
Protein Wisdom
Pursuing Holiness
Stones Cry Out
Sundries Shack
Rachel Lucas
Radiate His Light
Real Clear Politics
Right Wing News
Right Wing Nuthouse
Roman Catholic Vocations
Scribal Terror
Shrinkwrapped
Sissy Willis
Sister Toldjah
Small Dead Animals
Some Have Hats
Spiritual Things Matter
Sponsa-Christi
Sr. Genevieve Glen, OSB
St. Joseph's Monastery
St. Vincent's Abbey
Stop the ACLU
Sweetness & Light
Tammy Bruce
Tigerhawk
Tim Blair
Villainous Company
Visitation Sisters
Vita Nostra In Ecclesia
Volokh Conspiracy
Western Chauvinist
Witnessing Hope
Whispers in the Loggia
Wide Awake Cafe
Wintery Knight Blog
Wizbang
Word on Fire
Why I Am Catholic

« Previous  |Home|  Next »         

Wednesday, July 1, 2009, 1:51 PM
The_Anchoress

So, I was playing on Twitter during lunch and saw this one by Major Garrett blip by:

[WH Press Secretary Robert] Gibbs: “A very safe bet” that “dissenting views” to be heard at today’s HC town hall; defends hand-picked audience, pre-screened questions

Nothing to link to, yet, but I was stunned by the blip, which was corroborated by other MSM Tweeters, and even upset Helen Thomas.

So, Obama is having a so-called “town hall” meeting to promote his healthcare initiative, and he not only working before a “hand-picked” audience with “pre-screened questions,” and with newly-added screened, scripted and approved “dissent” with which he will be well-prepared to engage and heroically put down.

Evita Peron couldn’t have done it better. Nor could any current or historical despot I can think of. And yes, this is the Advanced Political Theater 101; Despotic Drama in Democracies.

Hmmmm…I remember when it was a terrible thing for a president to have a “pre-screened” and “hand-picked” audience at a Townhall, and how we read that such audiences were necessary because the president was so “hated,” and his policies so “deeply unpopular.” What are we to make of a “most beloved” president not only screening his audience but scripting the “dissent” he’s willing to address, as well?

No wonder the MSM seems to be running a new Michael Jackson headline every three minutes or so. All the better to pass quickly by stories that need real questions, like how cap n trade actually passed the house, and where is the “fine print” on it? Why do you root for despots and enemies while dissing our allies? If we lose half-a-million private-sector jobs in June, does that mean maybe rethink your stimulus? Should we think about lowering taxes, as Germany and Hungary are doing, in order to really stimulate the job-markets? Is capitalism as dead as this marxist says? Does Bush get any props for the success of the surge you and all your party denigrated or not? Does the WH really need to save us from our Nyquil, and um…what the hardest-working man in show business thinks about reports of dissenters being hanged in Iran?

I guess those dissenters did not get their scripts.

The press clearly has theirs.

UPDATE:
First memorable quote from this Town Hall – he wants to be judged: “not by promises I’ve made but by the promises that my administration keeps.” You’re right. It doesn’t make sense. It doesn’t have to.

And, “If the health care system were working well, I would be happy to leave it alone.” He says he has “plenty of other things”" to work on. Yeah, now he’s using your mother’s guilt-tactic. “I don’t have to be doing your laundry, you know, I have plenty of other things I could be doing. I’m only futzing with healthcare and working desperately to convince you that you need what does not work in Canada and England because you need this so badly. I don’t have to be here, you know. I could be doing a lot of other things. But I’ve condescended to be your president and gosh-darn it you will take this medicine if I have to be on tv 24/7, and Nancy Pelosi has to shove it down your throat with her angry little fist!” As usual, he doesn’t really want to do this. Just like he doesn’t really want to run the banks, run GM and ummm…support Iranians yearning to be free. Oh wait…that one might be real.

Further on in his “town hall” Obama tells his audience to reject those who say that Obama is proposing “a government takeover of health care.” Yes, the government is taking over health care, but you must reject that truth in favor of gooey language about “choice” and ummm…well, but the government is not taking over health care. You just tell everyone that, mmkay?

Bookworm: More on Political Theater: I have it on very good authority (an employee at US embassy in a major NATO country) that this year, in order to celebrate America’s (not Obama’s, but America’s) Independence day, all embassies have been ordered to install a big screen TV in a prominent location in order to play an endlessly looped Hillary Clinton speech for the duration of the festivities.

My employee contact notes that, at his particular embassy, people are appalled by this requirement. They see it as “tacky.” I see it as profoundly un-American. Indeed, I can think of only two precedents for this kind of thing. One is found in George Orwell’s 1984. In that book, as you may recall, all party members have in their living quarters TVs that may never go off and that sprout endless party propaganda (not to mention have cameras that watch everyone perpetually).

Read on…

More at Radio Patriot

From Mary Katharine Ham, via twitter How Obama campaign talked about McCain’s health care plan before it started pondering the same one, but with no offsetting tax credits:

More:
Sister Toldja
Michelle Malkin

12 Comments

    suek
    July 1st, 2009 | 2:58 pm | #1

    “If the health care system were working well, I would be happy to leave it alone.”

    Didn’t he use that same line – I mean that _exact_ same line – about the car company takeover?

    The Top and Bottom 10 States for Overall Freedoms « Jim Blazsik
    July 1st, 2009 | 3:14 pm | #2

    [...] Obama hardest working man in show business – The Anchoress [...]

    Sceptress
    July 1st, 2009 | 4:20 pm | #3

    We have a lazy press that relies on press releases for a huge portion of it’s content. We need wonks who will do the unglamorous gumshoe work.

    Dee
    July 1st, 2009 | 7:06 pm | #4

    Loved the clip of Helen Thomas’ scorn for the WH control of the press. Never thought I’d see the day when HT was upset with a liberal left admin.

    » The Press Fights Back! NoisyRoom.net: “Extremism in the defense of liberty is no vice. Moderation in the face of tyranny is no virtue.” Barry Goldwater
    July 1st, 2009 | 7:39 pm | #5

    [...] Hell may have just frozen over… Bravo Helen Thomas – media extremist! Also, check out The Anchoress: Obama hardest working man in show business – UPDATED [...]

    Maggie45
    July 2nd, 2009 | 12:40 am | #6

    Dee, I agree. I had to play it a couple of times. Thought I was seeing and hearing things.

    I’m praying really, really hard for our country.

    John
    July 2nd, 2009 | 4:21 am | #7

    My Republican Congressman says Cap and Trade will be good for America.

    And, he caught the Green River Killer.

    Did you catch the Green River Killer?

    No, no you didn’t.

    You can hear his interview here.
    http://www.mynorthwest.com/?nid=194&sid=184941

    Dave Reichert SPEAKS: says Cap and Trade will be good for America

    He argued that the expense would not be what the Heartland Institute, Heritage Foundation, and Wall Street Journal were predicting. He argued that it would cost around $.48 per day and that we would have better national security, more nuclear, coal and refining capabilities, and a cleaner environment with the bill. He argued that the conservative arguments against were mistaken, and that Washington specifically would be better off even though the bill was imperfect.

    And, he caught the Green River Killer.

    Yeah, it took him a couple of decades, but better late than never.

    I hear Fox was thinking about making the Series 24 about Reichert. But instead of showing 24 hours in a day they would have to make each episode a year.

    [Regardless of what your GOP Congressman, finder of Green River Killers, says, our Democrat President has said clearly that cap n trade will cause utility bills "to necessarily skyrocket." His words - admin]

    Rich Fader
    July 2nd, 2009 | 10:07 am | #8

    Okay, I’m pretty sure putting a Hillary speech on continuous loop on a big-screen in every US mission overseas constitutes cruelty to the staff. Not to mention any guests.

    Watcher of Weasels » Mid-Week Weasel: BBC and Amnesty International Team Up to Accuse Israel of War Crimes
    July 2nd, 2009 | 1:03 pm | #9

    [...] the Anchoress tears apart the staged Obama Townhall for health care “reform”. Share and [...]

    Who Would’ve Thought? WH Reporters Chip Reid and Helen Thomas Criticize Obama’s Manipulation of Media at Phony Town Hall (video) « Frugal Café Blog Zone
    July 2nd, 2009 | 1:42 pm | #10

    [...] on Iran; O’s obligatory press conference and The Helen Thomas award The Anchoress, First Things: Obama hardest working man in show business – UPDATED Sister Toldjah: Our celebrity President and his staged “town hall” meetings Pirate’s [...]

    The Anchoress — A First Things Blog
    July 3rd, 2009 | 11:18 am | #11

    [...] Hardest Working Man in Showbiz: that would be our theatrical president [...]

    Steynian 370 « Free Canuckistan!
    July 3rd, 2009 | 7:52 pm | #12

    [...] THE ENTERTAINER Obama: hardest working man in show business …. [...]