Ads


George Weigel

view all featured authors »

Spanish Showdown

In the fall of 2007, I spent a week in Spain, giving lectures, meeting with Spanish Catholic leaders, and making a hair-raising climb up several hundred scaffolding stairs to the top of Antoni Gaudi’s Basilica of the Sagrada Familia in Barcelona—preceded by Cardinal Stanislaw Dziwisz, John Paul II’s longtime secretary, who was doing the trip in a cassock (after confessing to me, sotto voce, that he wasn’t too fond of heights)! Over the course of numerous conversations in those days, it became clear that the government of Jose Luis Rodriguez Zapatero, in power since April 2004, was not simply secular in character but aggressively secularist.

Textbooks were being rewritten to enforce the government’s leftist view of modern Spanish history; students aiming for admission to prestigious universities would be required to give the “correct” answers about such traumas as the Spanish Civil War in order to pass their entrance exams. Street names were being changed to eradicate the memory of the politically disfavored from Spain’s past. Marriage had been legislatively redefined so that any two people, of whatever gender, could be civilly “married.” (Shortly after I left the country, another law enabled a Spaniard to enter a civil registry office and “change” his or her sex simply by making a declaration to a government bureaucrat that she was now he, or vice versa. Some things are so absurd that they compel ridicule, and this one prompted me to a knockoff from “My Fair Lady”: “The dame in Spain is mainly in the name.”)

In interviews with the Spanish press, I suggested that the 20th century had a name for a political program that tried to re-manufacture human nature while re-writing history: The name was “Stalinism,” which used to be considered a hateful thing. Zapatero’s Spain was not, of course, Stalin’s Soviet Union in the latter’s most brutal manifestations. Nor was the current Spanish government as crudely malevolent as the Spanish Stalinists of the late 1930s who, during the Spanish Civil War, murdered tens of thousands of priests and religious, often sadistically. The Zapatero government, I suggested, was far more clever. It would impose a hard-left agenda on Spain through legislation, step by step, rather like the frog being slowly boiled in a pot of water who doesn’t realize that death is at hand until it’s too late.

Recent events in Spain have done nothing to persuade me that these judgments were excessively harsh.

Pope Benedict XVI visited Spain last November, gave two spectacular homilies at Santiago de Compostela (on the Christian roots of Europe) and at the Sagrada Familia in Barcelona (on beauty as a pathway to God). Prime Minister Zapatero did not attend either event and spent the three days after the Pope’s departure denouncing Benedict XVI while campaigning in Catalonia.

In March, dozens of secularist student gangsters, armed with a megaphone and defamatory posters, crashed into the chapel of Madrid’s Complutense University while Catholic students were at prayer. The radicals shouted deprecations of the Church, Pope Benedict, and the Catholic clergy; several of their number, women, stood on the altar and undressed from the waste up; two of the striptease artists boasted of their lesbianism. This obscene spectacle in the Spanish capital came shortly after several Spanish churches throughout the country had been trashed.

All of which suggests that Spain is now Ground Zero in the European contest between Catholicism and the dictatorship of relativism. And the latter is precisely what the secularist radicals of Spain are up to: imposing their concept of freedom-as-license through coercive state power and intimidation-through-violence. Bizarre legislation that rewrites history and redefines human nature is the first half of the equation; gang violence is its new and ominous complement. A different kind of war has been declared on the Church.

It hardly seems accidental that these attacks against Catholic facilities have come in the months before World Youth Day 2011, which will be held in Madrid from August 16 through August 21. The gauntlet has been thrown down. A tremendous turnout at Madrid in five months will demonstrate that the challenge has been accepted.

George Weigel is Distinguished Senior Fellow of the Ethics and Public Policy Center in Washington, D.C.

Comments:

4.6.2011 | 11:59am
Jane says:
Another reason to have the debate now is the strong influence of Spain in Latin America. Though not a colonial master for almost two centuries at this point, there are of course strong cultural ties. My friends in Argentina have been devasted by the institution of same-sex marriage there.
4.6.2011 | 2:12pm
bierce says:
José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero has announced that he will not stand as the PSOE candidate for prime minister in the next general election in Spain:

http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/b5f24f3c-5dfa-11e0-b1d8-00144feab49a.html#axzz1IlP7IHOB

In typical Stalinist fashion, he has recently expanded his hard-left agenda to include severe deficit reduction, pension cuts, restrictions on collective bargaining and general austerity:

http://www.economist.com/node/18073408

In such an environment, Mr. Weigel's frog may freeze to death long before the water comes to a boil.
4.6.2011 | 2:25pm
Anti-Catholic violence was great before and during the Spanish Civil War. It must have something to do with the violent history of Spanish Catholicism.
4.6.2011 | 2:27pm
Tony says:
The reality is that Spain is dying, with its extremely low birth rate, and high unemployment. I lived in Spain during the 1980's, and feel very sad.

I suspect the next 50 years will be very chaotic around the world, with unexpected stresses and change in Europe and Asia (China with the world's most rapidly aging population and a new generation - starting in the 1970's - of spoiled adults who were only children).
4.6.2011 | 4:03pm
Henry James says:
What is the truth about Spain, the the Spanish Civil War?

It was in Spain of course, that the prototype of modern American religious conservatism began. Where classic Fasicism began: in the unholy alliance between elements of church and right-wing, nationalist politics. The party that Weigel seems to support, against the Left, was the model for the classic conflation of religion, with attachment to country. All that was the very heart of the movement that opposed the Left: Fascism. Which was based on political rightists, trying to co-opt religion. And then funelling all that into attachment to BIg Govenment and nation, and the army; attachement to even to a right wing fascist, repressive government and nationality. And to military interventionism.

I am not sure why George Weigel should be so supportive of the Fascist side of the Spanish Revolution. Of the movement that opposed Leftism - but that helped create and inspire Nazi-ism itself. And that next, started WW II.
4.6.2011 | 4:06pm
Norman,

Do you think it would do any good for the Spanish bishops to apologize for the wrongdoings the Church did in the past? Would it be worth it, since it is doubtful any of the hierarchy are Francoistas?
4.6.2011 | 4:21pm
norman - Or not. It's pretty much the behavior of all human beings everywhere, and Spanish Catholics are historically less rather than more violent than the average citizen of the world. We have been trained to have Feelings that they were worse over the last few centuries, but that doesn't make it objectively so.

To be clear, I am not giving a pass to Spanish colonialism, or Christians conveniently finding rich neighbors to be suddenly worthy of denouncing, or any of the the other horrors that Christians have participated in or even initiated over the centuries. I simply want it noted that it's never worse, and sometimes better, than what one finds by throwing darts at the globe and choosing a year.
4.6.2011 | 6:18pm
In mentioning the violence of Spanish Catholicism I meant the Spanish Inquisition and the treatment of Jews, conversos, and Muslims. FRANCOISM WAS NOT AN INFLUENCE ON NAZISM OR EVEN FASCISM BUT AN OUTGROWTH OF NATIONAL CATHOLICISM IN SPANISH HISTORY. The Left in Spain is anti-Catholic (save the Basques) for historical reasons.
4.6.2011 | 6:33pm
Anonymous 3 says:
Hope that many who plan to come for the World Youth Day would read up this article as well as similar ones on some of the past events in the history of this land that has given us such saints as St .Teresa of Avila and the great devotion to Bl.Mother as 'Our Lady of the Pillar ' related to her miraculous appearance to St.James .

Happened to read how the Council of Toledo in 589 saw the introduction of Christianity to Spain at an official level , how the participants had fasted and prayed for 3 days beforehand - a good part that can be cherished and emulated from that Council , along with the empasis of the truth proclaimed , of the Oneness of The Father and The Son - so that The Father hunger that manifests in perversions may be ameliorated by seeing The Son !

Seems the Jewish persecutions started around that time too , as well as history of other unjust deeds in ensuing years !

Hope Spain would emulate Philppines in being devotees of Divine mercy as a nation and reap the rewards of mercy from all such debts of the past !

And who knows - may be The Mother would make a surprise intervention , to turn the tide , by helping the turbulent crowds into the calm of a Mother's love !
4.6.2011 | 7:23pm
Henry James, you express very well every topic on the Spanish civil war as Zapatero does these days in my country. Only Zapatero as historian is not a very good one. The History is not white and black, Spanish history included .
4.6.2011 | 7:55pm
Don Roberto says:
Zapatero is an instrument of cultural degeneracy. Pobre España, so far from God, and so close to millions of Moslem immigrants.

@Jane, I have seen the same in México. Hollywood and its foreign equivalents are abetting this terrible moral decline. @ Norman and Henry, some of us are anti-*left* for historical (and theological) reasons.

4.6.2011 | 10:04pm
Kevin says:
The recent events in Spain described by Mr. Weigel are all too reminiscent of the early days of the French Revolution.
4.7.2011 | 8:07am
Michael PS says:
Don Roberto's remark about "Moslem immigrants" does scant justice to the valour of the thousands of Hakaris in the army of Morocco that accompanied General Franco to Spain and fought so gallantly in the Nationalist cause.
4.8.2011 | 5:16pm
Fair article, with one exception: Barcelona and the Sagrada Familia are in Catalunya, not Spain, and should be seen thus...just sayin'.
4.9.2011 | 4:41pm
PIUSxxx says:
If you try to turn a country into a confessional Catholic state there is bound to be a backlash sooner or later. ps Does ANYONE take Weigel seriously?
4.14.2011 | 4:56pm
mike alba says:
I watch Catholic-run programs in TVes Sunday morning and experience the profound religiosity among committed Catholics in Spain. The admirable work Spanish missionaries in Africa and Latin America will generate many blessings for the 'Madre Patria".

Catholic roots are too deeply embedded in the Spanish soul and Catholicism will experience a moral and spirtual resurgence

I am looking forward to regime change. Zapatero and his Socialists have been atrocious for free enterprise, foreign relations and destructive of the right of the unborn and the family
4.16.2011 | 3:42pm
Gonzalo says:
As a Spaniard, I can't agree more with Mr. Weigel. I'd say that he even missed some even more secularist and family-eroding policies of Zapatero like banning religion from school while imposing (against the will of the parents) a brand-new subject designed by the Government, "Educación para la ciudadanía", which pretends to brainwash children in moral relativism, antihuman sexuality, ultra-feminist and gay agendas; or the approval of the prescription-free acquisition of the morning-after pill even to children at 16 (we'll see an increase of sexual transmitted diseases in the next few years); etc.

At the same time, the awareness of the Catholics has increased - like in the "Mass for the Families" attended by one million people in Madrid every Christmas, the huge pro-life demonstrations, or the objection movement against EpC.

I wish and pray for the visit of the Pope this summer for the WYD; may it start a renewal and strengthening of people's Faith that yields fruits and starts a return to the Culture of Life.
5.3.2011 | 1:39am
Do you think it would do any good for the Spanish bishops to apologize for the wrongdoings the Church did in the past? Would it be worth it, since it is doubtful any of the hierarchy are Francoistas? To be clear, I am not giving a pass to Spanish colonialism, or Christians conveniently finding rich neighbors to be suddenly worthy of denouncing, or any of the the other horrors that Christians have participated in or even initiated over the centuries. I simply want it noted that it's never worse, and sometimes better, than what one finds by throwing darts at the globe and choosing a year.
5.4.2011 | 5:06pm
Macy Malleck says:
@Jane, I have seen the same in Mxico. Hollywood and its foreign equivalents are abetting this terrible moral decline. @ Norman and Henry, some of us are anti-*left* for historical (and theological) reasons. In mentioning the violence of Spanish Catholicism I meant the Spanish Inquisition and the treatment of Jews, conversos, and Muslims. FRANCOISM WAS NOT AN INFLUENCE ON NAZISM OR EVEN FASCISM BUT AN OUTGROWTH OF NATIONAL CATHOLICISM IN SPANISH HISTORY. The Left in Spain is anti-Catholic (save the Basques) for historical reasons.
12.6.2011 | 2:13pm
AKO says:
@Jane and Macy
"Another reason to have the debate now is the strong influence of Spain in Latin America. Though not a colonial master for almost two centuries at this point, there are of course strong cultural ties. My friends in Argentina have been devasted by the institution of same-sex marriage there."

Has same sex marriage really been that affected by fascism or the Spanish history?
type the text above in the box below

Links

Blogs

Find Us

Contact