UPDATE: I love the readers of SHS. I just heard from a nurse who has the original article and Schwartz’s Compassion and Choices affiliation is disclosed there. That means that the full ID was not published along with the article on-line. Not great, but definitely the best scenario in this situation. I have changed the title accordingly and deleted the text dealing with allegations of misleading by omission.
Yesterday, here at SHS, I criticized an article originally published in the American Nursing Journal, in which the author, “Judith Schwartz, Ph.D.”—her only identity in the on-line version—suggested that hospice nurses tell dying patients about matters like terminal sedation, starving themselves to death, etc.. I pointed out that much of what Schwartz advocates would exceed a nurse’s responsibilities.
I have since found out that Schwartz is actually deeply involved in the assisted suicide movement as the “Clinical Coordinator for Compassion & Choices in the Northeast and the Patient Support Coordinator for Compassion & Choices of New York. “ Yet, this important identifier was not included with the article—at least not as it appeared on-line.
Now that we know the ideological foundation for Schwartz’s opinion, readers have a far better ability to judge its sagacity.
America's most
influential
journal of
religion and
public life
Subscribe
Latest Issue
Support First Things
influential
journal of
religion and
public life
Subscribe
Latest Issue
Support First Things