A happy product of Tim Tebow’s persistent success has been the production of another proof for the existence of God. St. Paul in Romans 1:20, Aquinas’ five ways, Anselm’s ‘that than which,’ and Kant’s moral argument: Tim Tebow’s proof finds itself amidst sanctificetur disputatio . Allowing as an initial premise that all states of affairs in which obvious divine intervention occurs are states of affairs in which God exists, the Tebowlogical argument, in austere formulation, might run something like this:
1. If the Broncos score in the next 11 seconds, then the Broncos will win against the Steelers.
2. If the Broncos score and win, then it will be because of divine intervention.
3. But Tim Tebow plays for the Broncos.
C: Divine intervention necessarily obtains; the Broncos will score and win.
Because the conclusion coheres with reality (Demaryius Thomas caught an 80 yard pass from Tim Tebow, scoring a game-winning touchdown), we can therefore assume that ours is a state of affairs in which God exists.
Unfortunately, arguments from design like the Tebowlogical argument cannot withstand arguments from evil. So, if the Broncos do end up losing to New England on Saturday, advocates of the Tebowlogical argument are in trouble. Dr. William Irwin , a philosophy professor at King’s College in Pennsylvania, objects on different grounds :
“But the idea that God intervenes in NFL games is absurd. If God exists, he is not responding to Tebow’s prayers by helping him win games. God is, by definition, perfect-all knowing, all powerful, and all good. This means that God always will do all and only the right and best things. If he failed to do so, he would not be God. But either helping the Broncos win is the best thing to do, or it isn’t. If it is the best thing to do, then God will do it. That is what God does: the best thing.”
Even if Dr. Irwin is right that petitionary prayer is not efficacious and the concept violates divine immutability, he must then admit that, as far as anyone can tell, God is doing what is best by allowing Tim Tebow to win. Next will be to discern the biblical references in his total passing yards for each game: Against the Steelers, he had 316.
Thanks to Siris
While I have you, can I ask you something? I’ll be quick.
Twenty-five thousand people subscribe to First Things. Why can’t that be fifty thousand? Three million people read First Things online like you are right now. Why can’t that be four million?
Let’s stop saying “can’t.” Because it can. And your year-end gift of just $50, $100, or even $250 or more will make it possible.
How much would you give to introduce just one new person to First Things? What about ten people, or even a hundred? That’s the power of your charitable support.
Make your year-end gift now using this secure link or the button below.
