A very insightful column this weeekend from Ross Douthat :
Consider the secular vote, which has been growing swiftly and tilts heavily toward Democrats. The liberal image of a non-churchgoing American is probably the spiritual but not religious seeker, or the bright young atheist reading Richard Dawkins. But the typical unchurched American is just as often an underemployed working-class man, whose secularism is less an intellectual choice than a symptom of his disconnection from community in general.
What unites all of these stories is the growing failure of Americas local associations civic, familial, religious to foster stability, encourage solidarity and make mobility possible.
This is a crisis that the Republican Party often badly misunderstands, casting Democratic-leaning voters as lazy moochers or spoiled children seeking gifts (as a certain former Republican presidential nominee would have it) rather than recognizing the reality of their economic struggles.
But if conservatives dont acknowledge the crisiss economic component, liberalism often seems indifferent to its deeper social roots. The progressive bias toward the capital-F Future, the old left-wing suspicion of faith and domesticity, the fact that Democrats have benefited politically from these trends all of this makes it easy for liberals to just celebrate the emerging America, to minimize the costs of disrupted families and hollowed-out communities, and to treat the places where Americans have traditionally found solidarity outside the state (like the churches threatened by the Obama White Houses contraceptive mandate) as irritants or threats.
“Secularism is less an intellectual choice than a symptom of . . . disconnection from community in general” is an aphorism to which we will have to keep returning.