Support First Things by turning your adblocker off or by making a  donation. Thanks!

My selections get even more arbitrary here, because I’m both including songs deliberately seeking to revisit or rework the original sound, and ones that, perhaps unintentionally, to my mind evoke it. What is more, my knowledge gets spread more thinly here—I’m very spotty on candidates from the 90s and aughties, and the resultant list reflects my 80s youth.

1) Woods, “Cali in a Cup”

The title says it. Along with surf, folk-rock is one of the two genres that most evoke my home state, and there are some connections between the two—both prefer an echoey and even “watery” guitar sound that invites you to lose yourself inside of it. Woods are a contemporary band from Brooklyn, kinda psych-y, and prior to this latest album, defiantly lo-fi. Other songs are arguably superior contenders, but the title here and the video of a Highway 1 road trip to Big Sur, seal the deal.

2) Rainy Day, “I’ll Be Your Mirror”

Perhaps my absolute favorite in the genre. A cover, but the song’s beauty had been obscured by Nico’s singing. David Roback, of Rain Parade, then Opal, and then Mazzy Star, is the guitarist, doing a reverential rendering behind, and really all-around , Bangles star Susanna Hoffs at her dreamiest. The reverence is not for the original sound, but for the healing potential of Lou Reed’s lyric. Play as loudly as possible for the full folk-rock cathedral effect.

3) Big Star, “September Gurls”

The longing, the longing, the longing! The 70s group that inspired several of the 80s bands here.

Alex Chilton image

4) The Jam, “Tales from the River Bank”

True it’s a dream, mixed with nostalgia; but it’s dream that I’ll always hold onto, that I’ll always run to . . . A deeper reflection on the basic idea present in Elvis Costello’s “What’s So Funny ‘bout Peace, Love, and Understanding?” and Paul Weller, master evocater of young idealistic emotions, knew that lyrics like this deserved a folk-rock-ish backdrop, made both surreal and edgy with the feedback.

5) R.E.M. “Pretty Persuasion”

R.E.M.’s early sound was a reworking of folk-rock, and they’ve a number of songs from that era superior to this one, such as “Laughing,” “Gardening at Night,” “So. Central Rain,” and “Seven Chinese Brothers.” But I put “Pretty Persuasion” here because it shows you, particularly at the mid-way break beginning at 2:20, the way in which the guitar and harmony dynamics of the folk-rock sound, while so effective in the slower, meditative or ballad-ic numbers, can also be employed for incredibly emotional up-tempo effects.

6) Rain Parade, “What She’s Done to Your Mind”

Straight revivalism. And I’m all for it. Their more important song was “Blue,” and their typical sound, especially live, was more overtly psychedelic, but this captures the classic folk-rock vibe perfectly.

7) The Replacements, “16 Blue”

I assume this could be improved by someone employing a non-ragged vocal style, or just a better ragged style than poor Paul Westerberg can give us, although it’d be hard to improve on the playing, or on the song itself.

8) Game Theory, “24”

Studies show that folk-rock-ish moodiness is most strongly felt from ages 16 to 24. Game Theory leader Scott Miller was some kind of genius, at times over-praised for over-artiness such as the album Lolita Nation , but with a knack for reworking 60s pop/folk-rock sounds into the contemporary 80s ones of his day, and for very incisive lyrics. I’m sorry to report he passed away this year at age 54—sometime hope to discuss his somewhat “songbook”-like music blogging, collected in Music: What Happened? a taste of which can be found here .

9) The Church, “Almost with You”

Ignore the annoying name and séance video, close your eyes, and just get lost in it . . .

10) The Smiths, “Please, Please, Please, Let Me Get What I Want”

I think as Morrissey intended, I like this half on a sincere level of “yeah, I’ve felt that,” and half on an ironic level of admitting that sometimes “artistic soulfulness” is little more than mopey feeling sorry for oneself. That’s why I include this mere sketch out of a catalog of worthier Smiths’ songs —I want to remind us, with respect to the folk-rock vibe generally, that Xenophon would not approve!!! (But Agathon would.) C/c w/ something totally sincere (and which I more sincerely love) on the same theme from The Gants: “Never Go Right”

11) The Las, “There She Goes”

A little island of sparkling gentility in a depressing 90s sea of sludgy grunge and super-fat beats. One of the songs that makes me think that no, folk-rock is not really about a Tambourine Man or Times That-Are-A-Changin’, but at bottom about pining for some beloved.

13) The Allah-Las, “Tell Me What’s on Your Mind”

Not a few indie-rock folks are regarding their 2012 album as the best of that year, although it disturbs others that it is so revivalist. There’s no denying the perfectionist “curatorial” spirit of the Allah-Las’ sound, but one should note that they are exploring niches of the folk-rock sound not fully exploiting or appreciated in the 60s themselves: for one, the Cali connection between surf-guitar and folk-rock-guitar, and for two, the more garage-y side of folk-rock, the side commenter Charming Billy is onto, the Stonesy side that plausibly regards “Last Time” (listen to the guitar in it!) as being as much the first folk-rock song as “Mr. Tambourine Man.” A separate post soon on this truly excellent band.

Anyhow, what are your favorites?

image las

P.S. Yes, gentlemen, if you are caught singing along to Simon and Garfunkle or Game Theory songs you will be called an unmanly wimp, and perhaps for some good reasons, ones this boy didn’t understand when aged “16-to-24,” and nicely spelled out by Plato-loving schoolmaster Terrence Moore in his fine essay “Wimps and Barbarians.” For an approach to balancing the sensitivity and longing of the folk-rock vibe with manliness, one might consider the underrated West-Texas-rooted band the Bobby Fuller Four , who insisted upon a more American rock n’ roll way of responding to the Beatles sound, or more generally, one might look to the approach employed by most of the male Country singers. Who knew, for example, that even in a song as corny as “Kaw-Liga,” that a guy like Hank Williams could teach you a thing or two? Well, I didn’t know it when back in my teenaged suburban room with the likes of Brian Wilson, Scott Miller, Roger McGuinn, and Michael Stipe.

But man, if you’ve got no room in your heart for the sorts of songs I’ve been linking to, I feel sorry for you. As the Byrds sang, there is a season . . . . . . and a place, to every purpose, under heaven .

Comments are visible to subscribers only. Log in or subscribe to join the conversation.



Filter First Thoughts Posts

Related Articles