Aristotle and Touch

My colleague Jonathan McIntosh points to the Aristotelian source for Thomas’s views on touch: “we have a more precise sense of taste because it is a certain type of touch, and that is the most precise sense a human being has. For in the other sense, the human being is left behind by . . . . Continue Reading »

Gastronomic Epistemology, 2

Knowing is like tasting and eating.  Where does that get us? If knowing is like eating, then we know things other by taking them into ourselves.  Knowing is a kind of participation, union, indwelling.  If knowing is seeing, we keep everything at a distance. If knowing is like eating, . . . . Continue Reading »

Touch

Thomas says that “excellence of mind is proportionate to fineness of touch” rather than sight.  Why?  ”In the first place touch is the basis of sensitivity as a whole; for obviously the organ of touch pervades the whole body, so that the organ of each of the other senses . . . . Continue Reading »

Theology of food

Angel F. Mendez Montoya’s The Theology of Food: Eating and the Eucharist (Illuminations: Theory & Religion) is an explosive little book.  His “alimentary theology” is not just a theology of food; like Jeremy Begbie’s “theology with music,” Mendez Montoya . . . . Continue Reading »

Objectivity and Distance

Carolyn Korsmeyer ( Making Sense of Taste: Food and Philosophy ) questions the traditional hierarchy of the senses that places vision and hearing at the top of the heap.  Why do they come out on top?  Korsmeyer says that the issue is distance; distance keeps the thing perceived (seen, . . . . Continue Reading »

Gastronomic epistemology

Lisa Heldke writes, “For theories like Descartes’ [which] conceive of my body as an external appendage to my mind, and see its role in inquiry as merely to provide a set of (fairly reliable) sensory data on which my reasoning faculty then operates to produce objects of knowledge. . . . . Continue Reading »

Transubstantiation and humiliation

Kereszty acknowledges that recent theologians have objected to the “reification” of Christ’s presence in some scholastic theology: “They insist that the sacraments are a personal encounter between human beings and Jesus Christ himself.”  Talk of a change in the . . . . Continue Reading »

Why music?

Listen to the first four minutes of the first movement (Andante grave) of Prokofiev’s Cello Sonata in C Major, and ask yourself: Woudln’t you be content if these four minutes summed up the story of your life? . . . . Continue Reading »

Medieval Degeneration

In his Wedding Feast of the Lamb , Roch Kereszty briefly summarizes some of the ways that the Eucharist degenerated in the late medieval period: “Instead of stressing the building up of Christ’s body the church as the ultimate effect of the Eucharist, the Late Middle Ages saw the . . . . Continue Reading »

Arguments from Prophecy

Faustus complained that arguments from prophecy led only to vicious circles.  ”Believe in Jesus because of the prophets, he imagines a Christian telling a pagan.  ”I don’t believe the Hebrew prophets,” the pagan replies.  ”But Jesus endorses the Hebrew . . . . Continue Reading »