Age of Reason?

Powell ( The Moral Tradition of American Constitutionalism: A Theological Interpretation ) argues that the American system is largely a product of Enlightenment liberalism, embodying many of the features of the ideal Enlightened polities constructed by Locke, Montesquieu and others. He recognizes . . . . Continue Reading »

Storied law

In The Moral Tradition of American Constitutionalism: A Theological Interpretation , Duke Law’s H. Jefferson Powell describes the contribution that common law made to the American legal tradition, highlighting the fact that common law represented a tradition of legal story-telling into which . . . . Continue Reading »

Redaction blues

The always-innovative Michael Goulder wonders how and why redactors might have changed the text of Isaiah, as critics believe ( Isaiah As Liturgy , 1-2) : “Glosses in the margin may be believable for brief phrases like even the King of Assyria , but many of the supposed insertions are of a . . . . Continue Reading »

Hail the Status Quo?

A reader asked Orwell whether he intended Animal Farm to condemn revolution as such. Orwell said no: “Re. your query about Animal Farm . Of course I intended it primarily as a satire on the Russian revolution. But I did mean it to have a wider application in so much that I meant that that . . . . Continue Reading »

Tolkien’s poetry

In the TLS , Tom Shippey reviews Christopher Tolkien’s recent edition of his father’s The Fall of Arthur . The poem was the product of Tolkien’s early excursions into alliterative poetry, a project he shared with CS Lewis: “The later success of J. R. R. Tolkien and C. S. . . . . Continue Reading »

Why Andrew Sullivan is smiling

Scalia in dissent argues that the DOMA decision is already a decision about “traditional” state definitions of marriage: “the view that this Court will take of state prohibition of same-sex marriage is indicated beyond mistaking by today’s opinion. As I have said, the real . . . . Continue Reading »

The Rhetoric of the Majority

After offering some of the legal interests served by DOMA, Scalia in dissent notes the rhetoric of the majority opinion, which clearly resembles the rhetoric of gay rights activists. He chides his colleagues for treating Congress and the President who signed DOMA so cavalierly: “to defend . . . . Continue Reading »

What Hath SCOTUS Wrought?

Alito says that the Court has decided an ongoing debate between two views of marriage. “The first and older view, which I will call the ‘traditional’ or ‘conjugal’ view, sees marriage as an intrinsically opposite-sex institution. BLAG notes that virtually every . . . . Continue Reading »

Not ashamed

Jim Adams ( The Performative Nature and Functions of Isaiah 40-55 , 170) summarizes the theme of shame in Isaiah 40-55: “The verb occurs eleven times and primarily in the first section. In brief, those who will be shamed are Jacob-Israel’s opponents . . . , the worshipers and . . . . Continue Reading »

Reprobation as Christian Doctrine

Stephen Holmes ends God of Grace and God of Glory: An Account of the Theology of Jonathan Edwards with a critique of Reformed theologies of predestination, especially of reprobation. The critique doesn’t entail a denial of reprobation. Holmes instead argues that reprobation hasn’t been . . . . Continue Reading »