There are probably a number of legitimate perspectives that First Things could offer on Glenn Beck’s recent rally in Washington, D.C. As an evangelical who is allergic to civic religion, my take is likely to be extremely unpopular. I am a fervent believer in the need for Christianity to take its natural place as the prophetic voice in the public square. But something about Beck’s approach rubbed me the wrong way.
While I struggled to decide what to say, I discovered Russell Moore’s blistering essay . He says everything I wanted to say better than I could:
A Mormon television star stands in front of the Lincoln Memorial and calls American Christians to revival. He assembles some evangelical celebrities to give testimonies, and then preaches a God and country revivalism that leaves the evangelicals cheering that theyve heard the gospel, right there in the nations capital.
The news media pronounces him the new leader of Americas Christian conservative movement, and a flock of Americas Christian conservatives have no problem with that.
If youd told me that ten years ago, I would have assumed it was from the pages of an evangelical apocalyptic novel about the end-times. But its not. Its from this weeks headlines. And it is a scandal.
As Moore notes, the problem isn’t really Beck. The problem is believers trading the true faith for the syncretism of Christian-flavored civic religion:
Too often, and for too long, American Christianity has been a political agenda in search of a gospel useful enough to accommodate it. There is a liberation theology of the Left, and there is also a liberation theology of the Right, and both are at heart mammon worship. The liberation theology of the Left often wants a Barabbas, to fight off the oppressors as though our ultimate problem were the reign of Rome and not the reign of death. The liberation theology of the Right wants a golden calf, to represent religion and to remind us of all the economic security we had in Egypt. Both want a Caesar or a Pharaoh, not a Messiah.
Read the rest. What did you think? Do you side with Beck or Moore?