MEMBER LOGIN




Search First Things

Advanced Search

RSS

The Anchoress
Archives

Categories

Monthly


Recent Posts







Shop on-line at www.aquinasandmore.com
Find Me...








Email The Anchoress




The Joyful Mysteries
The Sorrowful Mysteries
The Glorious Mysteries
The Luminous Mysteries
Compline for 7 Nights
Litany Sacred Heart Jesus



Advertise on this blog









Bl. Pier Giorgio Frassati
Pray for Us




St. Philip Neri, my '10 Patron






Catholic New Media Awards

The 2008 Weblog Awards

The 2007 Weblog Awards

The 2006 Weblog Awards







Blogroll

Abbey St.Walburga
Ace O' Spades
Adoration Online
Afterburner
A Few Shiny Pebbles
A.J. Strata
Amy Alkon
Another Think
Ann Althouse
And You Thought/Cranky
Ambivablog
American Digest
American Thinker
American Papist
Archbishop Hilarion
Archbishop Timothy Dolan
Aussie Homilies
Bainbridge
Baldilocks
Betsy's Page
Beyond the Pale
Big Hollywood
BizzyBlog
Blue Crab Blvd
Bill Whittle
Bookworm Room
Brutally Honest
Busted Halo
Cardinal Sean's Blog
Catholic and Enjoying It
Catholic Answers
Catholic Manhattan
Catholic Media Review
Cathouse Chat
Cartago Delenda Est
Catholic Key
Classical Values
Cobb
Concord Pastor
Creative Minority Report
Crescat
Compulsive Copyeditor
Confederate Yankee
Contentions
Conversion Diary
Curt Jester
Danielle Bean
Dave Justus
David Warren
Dawn Eden
Day by Day Cartoon
Deacon's Bench
Desert Nuns
Divine Office (Daily Audio)
Doc is In
Doctor Zero
Dominican Nuns, Summit
Don Singleton
Don Surber
Doug Ross Journal
Dr. Melissa Clouthier
Dr. Helen
Dr. Sanity
Ed Driscoll
Eternity Road
Evangelical Outpost
Ezra Levant
Fausta's Blog
Fine Old Family
Five Feet of Fury
Flopping Aces
FSMG Blog
Fr. Dwight Longenecker
Fr. Steve's Blog
G.M. Roper
Gateway Pundit
Gay Patriot
Goldfish & Clowns
Happy Catholic
Headline Bistro
HillBuzz
Hootsbuddy
Hot Air
Hubble Telescope
In Light of Law
Ignatius Insight Scoop
Inside Catholic
Instapundit
J's CafeNette
Jules Crittenden
Just One Minute
Kentucky Packrat
Kim Priestap
Life as a Catholic
Little Miss Attila
Little Flowers
Little Oratory
Liturgy of the Hours
Lorie Byrd
Lucianne
Maggie's Farm
Mahsheed's Corner
Martha, Martha
Maternal Optimist
Mary's Aggies
Maxed Out Mama
McNamara's Blog
Meanwhile/in the Kitchen
Media Mythbusters
Michelle Malkin
Mike Rowe Works
Minding the Campus
Moderate Voice
Monsastic Musings
Musing Minds
My VRWC
Neo-Neocon
New Advent
New Wine
Newsbusters
NewsFifty
Noisy Room Blog
Nose on your Face (satire)
Obi's Sister
Okie on the Lam
One Cosmos
Paragraph Farmer
Passionist Nuns
Patterico
Paul Snatchko
People's Cube
Planet Gore
Phatmass
Pioneer Woman
Pope2You
Powerline Blog
Protein Wisdom
Pursuing Holiness
Stones Cry Out
Sundries Shack
Rachel Lucas
Radiate His Light
Real Clear Politics
Right Wing News
Right Wing Nuthouse
Roman Catholic Vocations
Runs With Angels
Scribal Terror
Shrinkwrapped
Sissy Willis
Sister Toldjah
Small Dead Animals
Some Have Hats
Spiritual Things Matter
Sponsa-Christi
Sr. Genevieve Glen, OSB
St. Joseph's Monastery
St. Vincent's Abbey
Stop the ACLU
Sweetness & Light
Tammy Bruce
Team Rubicon
Tigerhawk
Tim Blair
Villainous Company
Visitation Sisters
Vita Nostra In Ecclesia
Volokh Conspiracy
WDTPRS
Western Chauvinist
Witnessing Hope
Whispers in the Loggia
Wide Awake Cafe
Wintery Knight Blog
Wizbang
Word on Fire
Why I Am Catholic

« Previous  |Home|  Next »         

Tuesday, May 12, 2009, 1:55 PM
The_Anchoress

Good for her. In America, we should not be watching a person endure character assassination and the possible loss of livelihood because she has committed the sin of daring to hold a “politically incorrect” position. Carrie Prejean was asked a question and she answered it. In America, once upon a time, the people who referred to themselves as “liberal” believed that one was entitled to one’s opinion and to full respect for it. Currently in America, every diversity is celebrated except the diversity of thought. Sadly, some in the nation have decided that thuggery, rather than respectful, reasonable argument, is a more expedient means of persuasion. They think “agree, or be destroyed” is a legitimate argument, as is its flip-side; “shut up to be safe.”

What did I say a long time ago:

The fascist is whoever is trying to shut you up, shut you down, dis-employ you, silence you, cripple you or marginalize you for the crime of daring to fall out of step with the party and the conventional wisdom. Beware of them.

I guess we have moved beyond “beware of them.” Perhaps I should amend that to say, “be ready to fight them and for you constitutional right to live and work in freedom.”

And don’t think the fascists only exist in one party.

Let this be a lesson to young ladies everywhere, but especially young ladies who profess Christ; if you’re going to take off your top for a camera, be prepared (sooner or later) to have to answer for it, both in this world, and the next. But in this world, the chances are you will have to defend your nudity against the jeers, sneers and fake prudery of those “open-minded” folks who would never, for an instant, tolerate anyone telling them what they should or should not do with their own bodies, but will crucify you for the choices you made with your own. You’ll have to answer for it because when you profess yourself a Christian, you choose exile, and you will be held to a different standard, entirely, than the world’s.

And that is not a bad thing, but you girls must think about that.

In the next world, of course, you’ll have to answer to Christ, himself,
who is much more merciful than the rest of us. He will likely ask you why you threw your pearls before swine.

He may gently ask you if you realized at the time that your actions could lead others into sin, by helping them to treat another human being (you) as a “thing”.

And I can tell you from personal experience: that is one awful question to have to contemplate and answer. The day one realizes that one’s actions do not remain static, but pulse out into the world to touch others (like ripples of water in a pebble-tossed pond) is a day that brings you to your knees. You taste the lick of flame, and you cry out for mercy.

Thankfully, there is mercy.

Watch Ms. Prejean’s whole statement. She’s not much of a speaker, but she gets it across. Color me surprised and impressed.

Good for Donald Trump, too, who has seriously ticked off some members of the press.

UPDATE I: Sissy Willis talking about beautiful conservative women and the party of “no”. Also, Jules Crittenden wants Trump on the Supreme Court – calls him The Cheez Whiz Solomon. Beautiful!

UPDATE II: WELCOME Corner Readers! While you’re here, please look around. Today we’re also talking about rules of speech, and if you missed morning prayer, here is the podcast of Vespers of the feastday of Our Lady of Fatima. Also, do check out David Goldman’s extraordinary piece on torture, which I wish I’d written, and Joseph Bottum’s updated and very timely piece (with bonus audio) on the Obama/Notre Dame Kerfluffle. You’ll like.

Related:
Insty finds the hypocrisy
Melissa Clouthier: The Perils of being beautiful and conservative
Archbishop Chaput: The value of sin-sense (H/T)
Jake Tapper
American Digest: Mistaking feeling for thinking
Some thoughts on American Fascism here
Another Woman Speaking Out: good for her, too

10 Comments

    Bender B. Rodriguez
    May 12th, 2009 | 2:57 pm | #1

    Obama can always claim there was a teleprompter malfunction, but what’s Hillary’s excuse for giving the same answer as this christo-facist homophobe?

    newton
    May 12th, 2009 | 4:19 pm | #2

    You made an exceptional point, Anchoress. And I’m sure you have touched a few nerves here.

    My body is not bikini-worthy. Nowadays, three to four months after childbirth, forget it: you will never see me in one of those for the rest of my life. But I know that, even though I beautify it as much as I can, in the end, it doesn’t belong to me. Besides, the modeling/pageant industry is the human equivalent of feral cats ready to fight one another for turf. I’ve seen tomcats flying fur all over the place. That’s the catwalk industry for ya. I understand that Carrie had all good intentions, but being a Christian is the equivalent there of having an ugly face. Now she learned that, the hard way.

    Her modeling career is over. She will have to focus on other, more worthy talents.

    I learned a long time ago that, when you are a Christian, your body is a temple of the Holy Spirit, and is no longer your own.

    One other person who learned this lesson was Eduardo Verastegui, the actor and producer of the film Bella. (I watched some parts of it: I was in tears, I tell ya!) In this interview, he talks about that same lesson he learned – which is very related to what you have stated here.

    Do you say “the” or “thee” | The Anchoress
    May 12th, 2009 | 8:41 pm | #3

    [...] Prejean; cautionary tale for Christians [...]

    paul
    May 12th, 2009 | 11:43 pm | #4

    This is a brilliant post.
    You are gifted.
    Thank you.

    sisu
    May 13th, 2009 | 9:31 am | #5

    Carrie Prejean Trumps “Party of No”…

    “For the second time in four years, Miss USA has magically turned into high celebrity drama that builds and builds to a boiling point at which Trump himself must jump in to decide whether a Miss USA contestant will be……

    Crunchy Con
    May 13th, 2009 | 5:59 pm | #6

    Donald Trump saves Miss California…

    I can’t say that anybody comes off looking very good in the whole brouhaha over Miss California Carrie Prejean’s answer on gay marriage, which she claims cost her the Miss USA crown. I appreciate Donald Trump standing up for her,……

    More on “thee” & “thuh” | The Anchoress
    May 14th, 2009 | 1:32 pm | #7

    [...] Prejean; cautionary tale for Christians – UPDATED [...]

    Steynian 355 « Free Canuckistan!
    May 15th, 2009 | 3:35 pm | #8

    [...] MISS PREJEAN: cautionary tale for Christians …. [...]

    The Anchoress — A First Things Blog
    June 27th, 2009 | 5:37 pm | #9

    [...] a during the Carrie Prejean/Prop 8 kerfluffle, I wrote this: “…if you’re going to take off your top for a camera, be prepared (sooner or later) [...]

    The Anchoress — A First Things Blog
    August 6th, 2009 | 3:11 pm | #10

    [...] Repeat after me: The fascist is whoever is trying to shut you up, shut you down, dis-employ you, silence you, cripple you or marginalize you for the crime of daring to fall out of step with the party and the conventional wisdom. Beware of them. [...]