It’s back-to-school time. Soon, girls and boys will be saying goodbye to summer and heading back to the classroom. But we know that doesn’t mean they’ll get to books and learning. Many of today’s kids are heading to the classroom with their Blackberry or iPhone in hand, Facebook account active, and hyper-sexualized clothing on, even at a pre-pubescent age. Suffice it to say, they face some distractions.
Which is why parents, especially parents of teen and pre-teen daughters, should read Girls on the Edge, the latest book by doctor and psychologist Leonard Sax. Sax, also author of Boys Adrift (2009) and Why Gender Matters (2006), sees a lot of distractions keeping girls from healthy development today, and he lists what he finds to be the “four factors driving the new crisis for girls”: issues affecting sexual identity; the “cyberbubble,” including social-networking technologies like texting, sexting, and Facebook; teen obsessions ranging from hyper-competitiveness in school to anorexia and other self-harms; and environmental toxins that bring on premature puberty.
Take his first one, sexual identity, for instance. There’s no doubt girls are dressing sexier earlier these days. Sax recounts the story of one mom whose daughter had chosen as a Halloween costume a French maid outfit complete with “fishnet pantyhose and a frilly miniskirt.” She recalls, “This was an outfit marketed to ten-year-old girls. They even had it in smaller sizes!” “What’s weird,” she continues, is that “boys’ costumes haven’t changed that much from what boys wore when I was little. . . . Boys would dress up as Darth Vader or a Jedi knight or Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle. And they still do. But so many of the girls today, nine- and ten- and eleven-year-old girls seem to feel as thought they have to dress up in something really skanky. How come? I’ve never heard of a boy who wanted to dress up like a Chippendale’s dancer.”
She’s onto something: This sexualization seems to be affecting girls more than boys, and sexualization is different from healthy sexuality. As Sax sees it, girls who dress sexy “prior to the onset of puberty are not expressing their sexuality. . . . Dressing sexually in the absence of sexual desire is simply conformism.” As psychology professor Stephen Hinshaw of Berkekley sees it, “If girls pretend to be sexual before they are sexual, they’re going to find it much, much harder to connect to their own sexual feelings.”
What is it, then? Self-objectification, really. Girls who dress sexy before puberty, are putting themselves on display like objects, not for themselves but for others. As Sax sees it, “our culture pushes girls to define themselves in terms of how they look instead of helping them to develop a sense of who they are,” and this sets them up for depression, anxiety, and unsatisfying relationships in the future.
Think of a girl you know between the ages of 13 and 16 on Facebook today. Look at her profile picture: Is she smiling? Chances are, no. Chances are, we see someone who is making an expression that is saucy, or rolling-the-eyes irritated, or simply deer-in-the-headlights stoic, but chances are it’s not a smile. Something’s gotten between the girl and her smile, and, as Sax diagnoses it, it’s self-objectification: “As these girls get hyper-connected with their peers, they get disconnected with themselves.”
So it’s not too surprising, is it, that sexting is so prevalent. Sexting, the increasingly popular trend of texting sexually explicit messages or photos via cell phones between peers, is at self-objectifying at the core. In 2008, the National Campaign to Prevent Teen and Unplanned Pregnancy surveyed teens and young adults about sexting and posting explicit materials online and found that 39 percent of teens are sending or posting sexually suggestive messages, and 48 percent reported receiving such messages. Girls in great number are volunteering nude photos of themselves to boys, and it’s becoming a legal mess in many states, where it’s tough to distinguish this from child pornography.
And you can imagine how, with hyper-connected technologies, playground bullying has reached a new level. One Ohio girl, Jesse Logan, sent a nude photo of herself to a boyfriend who later sent the image on to other girls in her class; she was harassed to the point of skipping school and ultimately killed herself in 2008. While this is an extreme case, it touches on a real problem of how much more brutal cyberbullying can be for girls:
Cyberbullying can be completely anonymous. Twenty years ago, if a girl wanted to spread rumors about another girl, everybody would know who was doing it. That knowledge constrained what the bully might say. If you got too nasty, your nastiness could reflect badly on you. But now you can pretend to be a boy who’s just received sexual services from Leeanne, then post something about Leeanne online, and nobody will ever know you are actually a girl who invented the whole story to make Leeanne look bad.
All this, for Sax, perpetuates the great problem girls face today—a diminished sense of self, which leads a greater likelihood of experiencing depression, anxiety, and inclination to turn to drugs, alcohol, or other self-harming obsessions.
As Melinda Tankard Reist, in her recently published book Getting Real: Challenging the Sexualization of Girls, reports:
Eight-year-old girls are admitted to hospital with eating disorders. Schoolgirls develop ranking systems on the basis of “hotness,” resulting in guaranteed misery for the girl with the lowest ranking. Cyberspace has become a central area for bullying where girls are universally judged. Many feel they are dying a social death and disintegrate emotionally. For some, emotional disintegration leads to physical disintegration with the ultimate tragic outcome.
Of course we can’t turn back time and erase the sexualization kids face everywhere or rewind to the pre-Facebook days. But, with books like these, parents can increase their awareness of what kids are facing today and be more involved. Even parents with a laissez-faire attitude about teen sex and technology want their kids to do their best in school. And with matters of life and death increasingly on the line, one thing’s for sure: Math class is on the backburner.
But we have to ask ourselves: How did we get here? And where do we go from here?
Mary Rose Somarriba is the managing editor of First Things.
Comments:
And when they are a little older, they continue with what they've learned by on being the center of attention: by performing lesbian acts in public. Girls kissing girls was considered disgusting when I was in high school and that was only 1980. Now? It's done all the time, on college campuses, in bars, etc. And the more daring you are, the more popular you are. It has nothing to do with being gay; it's the new cleavage.
The coming two Feasts of St.Maximilian and Feast of Assumption particularly significant in relation to the above topics - why would family converastions not be permeated with such ...and these days, with internet , any parent can look up on Feast days, make it a homework part , for general discussion and to let children know that we are in battle , that there are persons out there under enemy influence ( happend to read at the St.mike- org site about a 7 y.o adopted child who was showing signs of demonic attacks may be .. natural mother was victime of rape ! )
The couple at the wedding at Cana took a vow of chastity for a year, under guidance of our Lord as per Bl.Emmerich . In our fallen world , chastity has its need and role ...children made aware of how sexuality is a powerful weapon in the enemy's hands ..how being chaste and being a friend of God, they too hold lots of power ..even to prevent wars ..
There are examples of bl.Jacinta , Maria Goretti...and when children become friends with them , would not their help be there too..
then ofcourse introducing them to the ocean of mercy , to bring in the waves of peace ..as described in the book 'Consoling heart of Jesus ' - by the way , a good book that even preteens could find interesting for its 'cool' style :)
Should any family be without the evening rosary ... hearing our Mother loved and praised , with words from heaven ..'Hail Mary ..' , would not that love and affirmation sink in ..to drive out all the wedges that the enemy tries to bring between parents and children these days ..
may our ardent pleading in of The Spirit drive out what is not of God , take possession of all that He has given us , to be lifted up , with our Mother !
This is indeed sad. And no doubt the public culture is the greased tarp down which these kids are sliding.
But I don't see this as inevitable or necessary, nor do I believe the problem is much greater with one gender than the other. I also see a lot of kids who really seem to have their acts together. Our boys are in high school and middle school, and their lives are full of innocent interests, as seem to be the lives of many of their friends. Sure, we have to shew them away from machines about ten times a day, but they do as well or better in school as we did, and have most their fun outside or with the dog. And girls on average seem to do better than boys in school, and can be seen playing soccer in large numbers as nearby playfields.
What it seems to be, mainly, is a kind of caste system in the public schools. There is a loss of shame among many, and that is tragic. I don't think it's quite that hopeless, though. Despite the power of mass media, the war still needs to be fought as it has always been fought, one soul at a time.
There are a lot of information for parents that can assist them in these situation. Find out more by checking out our site.
As a father of four teenage daughters, not only have I been proven completely right in virtually all of my objections to feminism, (circa 1979) but I have discovered more pernicious consequences of it. In the area of teenage girls' hypersexualization, let me draw attention to the triumph of the movement to "empower" girls. The overwhelming message in media, in schools, in entertainment, in government is that girls need empowerment. While I have little respect for the judgement of teenage girls (subject for another posting) in this area they have shown keen insight. If empowerment is what a teenage girl is seeking, guess what is her greatest weapon is.
Friend 1: picture of girl with friend, smiling.
Friend 2: picture of girl making a funny face and taking a picture of herself with a cell phone. (Clever, not disturbing.)
Friend 3: Smiling picture.
Friend 4: picture of group of friends on the beach, goofing off, many smiling, all fully clothed.
Friend 5: Smiling picture.
Wait -- where are the saucy, or rolling-the-eyes, or stoic, or otherwise disturbing expressions? what am I doing wrong? How many friends of my daughter will I have to go through before I find the disturbing expressions?
But it is not just the sexual effects brought on by the new technological age - it is also the social effects. I do not know if anyone else here has noticed such a change in the last 10 years or so on a number of different social and interactive fronts, such as returning messages, relaying important information, confronting people and issues in person, etc.
A friend of mine at Franciscan University wrote an excellent thesis on the effects of increased use of technology on social intelligence and mastery. They are inversely proportional - which should go without saying, but apparently not everyone is so aware, and many of those who are either do not care or are not willing to change (it has become an "addiction" for many).
As far as the subject of the article is concerned, I wholeheartedly agree with the thesis. I would add that I only rarely get smiles returned by children when given in public. ("Something’s gotten between the girl and her smile, and, as Sax diagnoses it, it’s self-objectification: “As these girls get hyper-connected with their peers, they get disconnected with themselves.”")
My oldest child is coming up on 9 (a girl) and, since her birth, I have become more aware of *other* children. It began to startle me after awhile that when I smile at children in a public setting, I only rarely get a returned smile. That often goes for adults, too, if eye contact is even made. I am on a one-woman mission to return an experience of normal civil behavior (smiles in passing, normal greetings, holding doors, waving at passing cars in neighborhoods, etc.) to those that I encounter.
Perhaps part of the teen girls' behavior is simply a "ramping-up" of a response to the lack of normal social exchanges and friendships? A cry for attention, as it were?
If that is the case, then what must we who see it do in response?


