There is a simple truth about business: individuals, not “the organization” or “the law,” make the moral decisions behind each and every action a business takes. In a piece just released by the Pontifical Council for Justice and Peace, this vital point is highlighted: the unequivocal responsibility of the individual within the business context is at the center of every major business crisis and success we’ve experienced from the Wall Street mortgage meltdowns and the lingering echoes of Enron to inspiring entrepreneurs starting companies that cure cancer and bring essential services to poor families.
From this new reflection on the vocation of the business leader we learn that it is our individual aim that matters, not only the “system,” the environment, the perceived cultural or institutional constraints on our actions. No sum of laws and regulations prevent malignant intentions from achieving their goal. Personal responsibility, then, must be a part of any solution to corruption, power-mongering, and cheating in any aspect of human action, business included.
Wise business leaders, the document points out, create both profit and well being; “just wages for employees, just prices for customers and suppliers, just taxes for the community, and just returns for owners.”
It is true that sometimes we encounter an obsessive focus on financial profit to the exclusion of any other aspect in business; but this is a symptom, not a cause. The cause is the practice of separating our business from our faith and moral life. “Dividing the demands of one’s faith from one’s work in business is a fundamental error which contributes much to the damage done by business in our world today, including overwork to the detriment of family or spiritual life, an unhealthy attachment to power to the detriment of one’s own good, and the abuse of economic power in order to make even greater economic gains.”
Most business professionals know this and are searching for answers and ways out of that division of their lives. Thus the business community represents a fertile field for the practice of the Gospels and this is, I think, the aim of the Justice and Peace document.
It is, alas, common in our age to separate faith from business and promote a dualism between secular and holy.
The Church represents a counterpoint to that worldview: At the root of Christianity stands the fact that our path to spiritual fulfillment passes through our physical life and actions. Jewish and Christian faith is not only spiritual but also physical. Judaism emphasizes this by focusing on an actual city in this world: Jerusalem and a single historical people, the Jewish people. Christianity emphasizes the incarnate nature of the divine. On the last day, we will be raised in both body and spirit.
The document is a loud and clear call to a strong inner life for business leaders. It is also a call to develop among them a “spirituality of work.” It is even more important to provide a religious “formation” for business leaders and for students in our universities. We have long done the latter. We have barely begun the former.
Justice and Peace picks up Michael Novak’s call for the inculturation of our faith in the inventive, free market economy.
This document is the first draft of a remarkable vision: “The vocation of the businessperson is a genuine human and Christian calling. Its importance in the life of the Church and in the world economy can hardly be overstated.” The business vocation is “God's calling to be collaborators in creation.” Businesses and the free market "make an irreplaceable contribution to the material and even the spiritual well-being of humankind.” “Where businesses succeed, people's lives can be significantly improved; but where they fail, great harm can result.”
There are internal and external obstacles to living out this vocation well: Externally, the document points out, many are impeded by an absence of the rule of law, corruption, destructive competition, excessive state intervention or, in other places a culture hostile to entrepreneurship.
Internally to the firm, there are other obstacles: regarding the workforce as a mere “resource,” and the company as mere impersonal, irresponsible organization. Other obstacles are the rejection of the proper role of government regulation, allowing inferior products and services to go forward, and the heedless waste of natural and human resources.
Does business help you become holy? For everybody, holiness is found in doing ordinary daily tasks with an awareness of their importance to our God, and with Gratitude to him. If we try to perform everyday things in a way that will please and honor him, we follow his law and fulfill his even higher expectations.
Andreas Widmer is President of the Carpenter’s Fund and the author of The Pope & The CEO: John Paul's Leadership Lessons to a Young Swiss Guard. You can find him online at www.thepopeandtheceo.com and on Twitter @andreaswidmer.
RESOURCES
Pontifical Council for Justice and Peace, Vocation of the Business Leader
Become a fan of First Things on Facebook, subscribe to First Things via RSS, and follow First Things on Twitter.
Comments:
1) The corporation is solely concerned and exists only for profits.
How many conservatives would be found to disagree with the above proposition?
This dogma is the result of the ideas of Economists from Adam Smith on, that
the pursuit of self-interest is sufficient to organize a society. The common good, if any, shall be an incidental by-product of the pursuit of self-interest.
This is in total contrast to the thoughts of all writers before 18C.
Unless this point is recognized, the Church is unlikely to make much headway.
Why does not Church applies Natural Law to business endeavors? What is the use of vague statements calling for just wages and just prices?. he economists and conservatives laugh at these concepts.
Bob - I agree: having the Gospels as a guidepost is essential.
Philip - i agree: for those who have not seen them, Father Sirico's booklet and the movie that was made from it can be found at http://www.calloftheentrepreneur.com/
Gian - I think what we can all work on is to rediscover the beautiful Catholic "both, and" approach and integrate what seems to be opposites.
Edmond, of course this is so. The document points out very clearly that as business persons, we have to ask if the goods we sell are truly good, and if the services we provide truly serve. I would say that this includes how they're made and sold. This is the importance of the personal responsibility aspect, including that in which we choose to sell and how we source and produce those items.
Thank you for posting that website, I'll have to take a look at that booklet. As a young entrepreneur myself I am constantly fighting the battle of feeling greedy for wanting to be successful. I think that as long as your success comes fairly, and through hard work, it's not all that bad to be 'on top'.
To paraphrase Christ, "Love God, Love neighbor-the whole law hangs on this."
So, we honor the living Eucharist, and we work for the Common Good as our temporal goal. Solidarity. subsidiarity, distributism (more ownership by as many possible of the means of production) and perhaps a necessary ecological conversion of the economy.
I believe this is the work of integrated Christian business people. Let's make it happen.
The beauty and majesty of God's plan for those of us in business is evidenced by the concept of superabundance. Working our business in concert with God's plan has allowed us to see the effects of superabundance first hand. The real challenge is to convince others that this is not just luck, good fortune, or solely the result of hard work, but truly is a gift from God. Most folks simply can't get their arms around the simplicity of this great gift.
We continue to give credit where credit is due - to God.


