When we go off to college, we’re not yet adults but no longer children, and we’re often on our own for the first time. No more bells ringing between classes, the everyday routines of high school are behind us. Our parents aren’t around to wake us up in the morning—or to set a curfew. For the most part we’re responsible for and to ourselves.
Therein lies opportunity and peril. College is a time when we can take full, adult possession of our faith, and it’s also a time when it can slip away, either because of neglect, or intellectual challenges we’re unprepared to meet, or because we find ourselves swept up into the comfortable hedonism that tends to dominate the undergraduate culture of most American colleges.
What to do?
The most important piece of advice I can give: don’t put your spiritual life on hold! During your first semester of college there are many new people to meet, as well as new experiences to have, and fascinating ideas to entertain. That’s as it should be. But it’s easy to get swept up into all this and say, “I don’t have time, but I’ll get back to my faith someday.”
Someday needs to be now. Start with worship. Faith is not a do-it-yourself project. We need to participate in the sacraments. If you want to get run over by a train, you need to put yourself in its way. That same holds for God’s grace. For Catholics, attending Mass daily and regular confession is like going to the gym. We can’t stay spiritually fit unless we’re willing to commit the time. That holds true for Protestants as well, and different traditions prescribe different ways to give time to God every day.
For nearly everyone, college is a time of introspection and self-examination. What do I believe? What do I want to do with my life? What about love, sex, and marriage? It’s important that we ask these questions in the company of Christ. That requires a discipline of our interior lives to complement regular church attendance.
The spiritual writers identify three ways to make Christ more present to us in our daily lives: prayer, mortification, and charity. Prayer is a no-brainer. How can God talk to you if you’re not listening? Listening involves disposing ourselves internally toward God. We need to approach Him, as it were, which involves petitions and requests for illumination.
Mortification sounds intimidating and vaguely medieval. But the concept is easy to understand. For most of us the most important person in our lives is . . . me. In order to draw closer to Christ, we need to learn how to set aside our preoccupation with ourselves, which is another way of saying we need to practice self-denial. It’s not easy, and the great spiritual writers urge us to train our wills in self-denial. This need not involve grand gestures. In fact, that can be a danger, because we can become very proud of our mortifications—which is the very opposite of self-denial!
Therefore, the best approach is to make small sacrifices. Make a vow to wake up and go to breakfast every morning, even if your first class isn’t until 11 a.m. Choose a plain cheese pizza rather than pepperoni. You’ll be surprised how these tiny sacrifices work an interior magic, shifting your focus every so slightly away from yourself. Once you’re a little bit to the side, God can come to the center.
The final way of interior union with Christ involves charity. Christ gave himself for us on the cross. The slightest gift we give to others—a sympathetic ear, making time during exam week, calling your parents (and not texting!)—these acts participate in Christ’s cross, and thus in a small but real way unify us with him. And of course making time once a week or once a month to participate in a program that serves those in need does the same, with the added grace of fulfilling Christ’s commands to do the corporal works of mercy (Matthew 25).
I’ve emphasized sacramental and interior spiritual disciplines because I’m convinced that they provide the surest foundations for faith. We all face challenges and temptations in our lives, and that’s especially true for college students in academic environments often hostile to faith—and in dorm cultures hostile to even the most basic forms of moral rectitude. Our good ideas and pious intentions will be swept aside unless they are deeply rooted in our souls.
However, college students should keep some other things in mind.
First, we’re strongly influenced by the company we keep, and therefore we should seek the fellowship of other believers. The modern university is something of a fraternity for secularism. This is often true of Catholic universities, in spite of their best efforts. Nearly all colleges and universities have ministries that provide opportunities to connect and join fraternities of faith. Be sure you do so.
Second, find good mentors. This can be a priest or a pastor, but don’t limit yourself. Your college years have an academic focus, and ideally your intellectual development won’t be a separate compartment of your life, but will instead contribute to your maturity in faith. So it’s very helpful to have a mentor from inside the academic culture: a professor, perhaps, or a graduate student. Someone who has walked the path can help you find your way.
Third and finally, Pope Benedict refers to the books in his personal library as his trusted advisors. We can find mentors in authors. So read books that promise to deepen your faith and arm you with the arguments you need to give good reasons for the hope that is within you (1 Peter 3:15).
And not just books. There’s a good magazine I know that might be of some help. First Things offers a special student rate of $15 for ten issues per year. Just call us at 1-877-905-9920 or contact us by email: customer_service@first-things.com.
R.R. Reno is Editor of First Things. He is the general editor of the Brazos Theological Commentary on the Bible and author of the volume on Genesis. His previous “On the Square” articles can be found here.
Become a fan of First Things on Facebook, subscribe to First Things via RSS, and follow First Things on Twitter.
Comments:
Are you seriously comparing the the thoughtful religious conversions born of serious intellectual inquiry and reflection as well as spiritual awakening by fully-formed adults to the LOSS of religious conviction that often results from the predatory and stifling enculturation of hedonism, nihilism and secularism that is the echo chamber of the modern academy- by people who are to young young and naive to resist external influence?
Not sure what others would say, but... I think it requires a heart that is open to where the Holy Spirit is leading.
Dr. Reno isn't saying "stay inside your own little religious bubble" - he's saying that we need to be serious about continuing to practice our faith, trusting that the Holy Spirit will work through the Word and Sacraments to increase our faith and speak to our hearts.
Neuhaus, Newman, and St. Paul were all ardent practitioners of their respective faiths, and each was called to conversion by the Holy Spirit even as they were practicing the faith from which they were called away.
Taking seriously one's faith and one's commitment to that faith involves not just participating in the rituals, but also an openness to the Holy Spirit - whatever he may have to teach us, i.e., a continual seeking of the Truth and a willingness to see and engage whatever parts of it are being revealed.
Further, there's an intellectual component to conversion, but that wasn't really the point of this article, which is more about the spiritual disciplines. However, it is briefly mentioned in this sentence:
Your college years have an academic focus, and ideally your intellectual development won’t be a separate compartment of your life, but will instead contribute to your maturity in faith.
If one is being called to conversion (whether to Christianity in general, or Catholicism, whatever), there is a certain maturity of faith that is required to discern and answer that call, and a mentor of the type mentioned above can help one work out the intellectual and spiritual dimensions of that call.
You ask: "Are you seriously comparing the the thoughtful religious conversions . . . "
I am not comparing St. Paul falling from his horse on the road to Damascus to a teenager going off to college and ceasing to pay any attention to religion. I am asking how a person—any person—can know if he or she is correctly resisting doubts or "self-indoctrinating." It is a serious question, not an invitation to express outrage at me for asking it. What is your answer?
It's one of two questions that have been on my mind since high school. One, in seeking to bolster weak faith, how can one be sure one is not indoctrinating oneself? Two, how can I justify having so much when others have nothing?
Prayer for the Light of Truth
O my God, I confess that Thou canst enlighten my darkness. I confess that Thou alone canst. I wish my darkness to be enlightened. I do not know whether Thou wilt: but that Thou canst and that I wish, are sufficient reasons for me to ask, what Thou at least hast not forbidden my asking. I hereby promise that by Your grace which I am asking, I will embrace whatever I at length feel certain is the truth, if ever I come to be certain. And by Your grace I will guard against all self-deceit which may lead me to take what nature would have, rather than what reason approves.
@Timothy Anderson
Thank you for taking the question seriously and taking time to write thoughtful replies.
One most likely is indoctrinating oneself. At the same time, one would have to be naive not to realise that inculcating particular worldviews/ideologies and discouraging others (i.e. indoctrination) is a big part of what educational institutions do.
At least if you are indoctrinating yourself you will know why you are doing it, and will have some control over the process :-)
Ok, it's a legitimate question, but I resubmit that is unrelated to the premise of the essay, because large numbers of college attendees lose (all) faith?
You have essentially asked "what is truth" and by what means will I recognize it? That is a timeless question outside the scope of a few hundred words.
the only reason you should believe anything is that it's true. a proposition is true if it accords with reality. how do we know if propositions accord with reality? by reason, experience, and authority. of course it will be YOUR reason operating all along, but it might be others' experience and authority still filtered through YOUR reason. therefore, admittedly, no one can escape his/her self.
when i declared that i submit to the authority of christ through his church, even in the act of submission can be found that very important pronoun "i." it is i who submit. see john henry newman's toast to conscience, which has been wildly misinterpreted ever since as a defense of subjectivism.
in sum, wisdom is the right response to reality. and all who desire happiness ought to seek wisdom. which includes college students.
Yes, that is essentially what he's asking. And frankly, I think his question is 100% relevant to the topic of the essay. Since the essay is concerned with how to hold onto your faith in college (in other words, how to defend what you know as "truth" in your heart), then his question is absolutely legitimate and we shouldn't patronize him for asking it.
Besides, who made you moderator of the discussion?
I went to Public High School and was more encouraged in my faith life by my brothers in Christ from other churches than I ever have been here away in college. I felt the call to the priesthood and that is why I decided to study theology but I have applied to several dioceses and been rejected because I am “disabled” and would not be of any use to them. So for graduate school I am going to Public University and I say go Obama and force the churches to comply with the law!
“The modern university is something of a fraternity for secularism. This is often true of Catholic universities, in spite of their best efforts”
I would like to ask what catholic institutions he is referring to – I currently attend a catholic university and it is very traditional which sometimes leads to a attitude of clericalism that pushes people out of the church.
“So read books that promise to deepen your faith and arm you with the arguments you need to give good reasons for the hope that is within you”
With normal studies and jobs that students have when does he think we will have the time to do such lofty endeavors. We should be concerned with the pastoral needs of the students instead of just their spiritual life – are they having a problem with their girlfriend, are their parents out of work, are they facing sickness, and then once we have established a relationship through a caring ministry then they will feel comfortable talking about the existential quagmires of life.
"Besides, who made you moderator of the discussion?"
Nobody-the same party that made you moderator.
"Adam Baum, the Grand Inquisitor. "
If you can't make an effective counter-argument, you can always resort to name-calling.



How does a person tell the difference between holding on to authentic faith and indoctrinating himself or herself? And how appropriate would it be in any other area to take pains to make sure you believed the same thing when you left college as you did when you left high school?
How would most of us feel about a college student who was raised as a fundamentalist and young-earth creationist who struggled valiantly to remain so in college?