Entering St Josephs in Yorkville for the first time, I found it a pleasure to look aroundto view the exquisite stained-glass windows in the sanctuary and to peer upward at the less outstanding but still worthy ceiling murals of scenes from the lives of Jesus and Mary. Originally founded to serve German-speaking Catholic immigrants, St. Josephs achieved a bit of fameand subsequent growthin 2008, when Pope Benedict XVI visited it during his trip to the United States. The parish is particularly proud of the chalice and paten, now on display, that the pope gave to the pastor.
On Sunday, April 18, the principal liturgy at 11:00 A.M was in many ways a typical American example of a vernacular Mass according to the ordinary form, or what many tradition-minded Catholics call the Novus Ordo . Still, it was more reverently and rubrically conducted than at many parishes. Fr. Matthew Yatkauskas, the parochial vicar, or curate, of the parish, was the celebrant and homilist. He exuded faith, piety, and precision of thought. In this reviewers opinion, however, Fr. Yatkauskas homily did not say all that the Churchs current situation calls for.
The Gospel passage on which Fr. Yatkauskas preached was John 21:119, which centers on the appearance of the risen Jesus to Peter and some of the other apostles on a morning after the men have spent a night fishing fruitlessly in the Sea of Galilee. Fr. Yatkauskas noted that the apostles exemplify how slow most Christians are to develop a lively faith: Even after the apostles have seen the risen Lord twice, their thought is to return to their old way of life. Their works nightlong failure, and the minor miracle of the huge catch to which the Lord alerts them at dawn, shows that he wants them to become fishers of men. By eating breakfast with them, Jesus also assures them that he is no ghost or figment of their imaginations.
The climax of this rich passage is, of course, Jesus asking Peter three times whether he loves him. This gives Peter the opportunity, which he takes, to expiate his three denials of Jesus after Jesus arrest. Fr. Yatkauskas effectively applied this lesson for each individual believer. But he did not say what is significant for the Church as a whole about the commission Jesus gives to Peter with the words Feed my lambs; tend my sheep.
According to Catholic understanding, Peter was the first pope, and the role of the papacy is precisely to tend the universal Church as pastor, or shepherd. At a time when the pope is under ferocious assault for what is perceived as a major failure in this regard, it would have been quite timely for the homilist to explain to the faithful how it is possible for popes to correct and atone for such failures.
City: New York
Address: 404 Eat 87th Street
Denomination: Roman Catholic
Main Service: 11:00 a.m. Sunday
Pastor: Fr. James Boniface Ramsey; celebrant and homilist at this liturgy, parochial vicar Fr. Matthew Yatkauskas
We launched the First Things 2023 Year-End Campaign to keep articles like the one you just read free of charge to everyone.
Measured in dollars and cents, this doesn't make sense. But consider who is able to read First Things: pastors and priests, college students and professors, young professionals and families. Last year, we had more than three million unique readers on firstthings.com.
Informing and inspiring these people is why First Things doesn't only think in terms of dollars and cents. And it's why we urgently need your year-end support.
Will you give today?