With the release of her book Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother and her article in the WSJ on ” Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior ,” Yale Law School professor Amy Chua ignited a debate about what constitutes “successful” parenting.
Pamela J. Nielsen considers the question from the perspective of vocation :
If you are a parent, your children are your vocation and your most important calling. God sets the standard for you: Fathers, do not provoke your children to anger, but bring them up in the discipline and instruction of the Lord (Eph. 6:4). To raise your children in the discipline and instruction of the Lord is to raise children with Gods Word, in His Church, where His gifts of forgiveness, life and salvation are given to all who believe. These are the first things for Christian moms, dads and children.
In sharp contrast, Ms. Chua and many others have determined quite a different standard or set of first things in raising their children. Were familiar with them because we have been tempted to make them primary in our homes too: good grades, first place, social standing, perfect performances and winning championships. These are the worlds marks of success, but they are not Gods. In our efforts to achieve these worldly standards, sometimes the first thing of bringing our children up in the discipline and instruction of the Lord becomes a second, third or fourth thing.
How? When we frequently skip church and Sunday School for team practice or tournaments. When we complain that Pastors assignments and requirements for confirmation are too much, even as we pay for extra tutoring in math for our child. When we disdain helping our children with learning Bible verses and the catechism while spending long hours creating the perfect science project.
The doctrine of vocation puts these things in their proper order.
(Via: Gene Veith )